Eyeliner Reviews

Trying to figure out which eyeliner is best for you? Can't decide between cake eyeliner and liquid eyeliner? Whether your look is classic, emo, goth or funky, read our eyeliner reviews to find the best liquid eyeliner, waterproof eyeliner, quick drying eyeliner, gel eyeliner and more.

Find out if MAC eyeliner is really better than Mary Kay eyeliner. Trying to decide between Cover Girl eyeliner, Avon eyeliner and Rimmel eyeliner? Let our members tell you which brand is their favorite.


Popular Shortcuts

subscribe to reviews about
Eye Makeup



results filtered by: remove all filters


Best Quick Drying Eyeliner


Wet 'n Wild Liquid Eyeliner

Wet 'n Wild Liquid Eyeliner

Wet and Wild H20 is the best liquid eyeliner on the market
4.5 star rating 4.405 reviews review it

 


CoverGirl LineExact Liquid Eyeliner

CoverGirl LineExact Liquid Eyeliner

A quality and affordable liquid eyeliner by CoverGirl...
4 star rating 4.2015 reviews review it



Avon Daring Definition Gel Eyeliner


Quick Drying Eyeliner reviews


Best Waterproof Eyeliner


Wet 'n Wild Liquid Eyeliner

Wet 'n Wild Liquid Eyeliner

Wet and Wild H20 is the best liquid eyeliner on the market
4.5 star rating 4.405 reviews review it

 


Smashbox Jet Set Waterproof Eye Liner

Smashbox Jet Set Waterproof Eye Liner

SMASHBOX JET SET IS THE BEST I'VE TRIED
4 star rating 4.004 reviews review it

 


Wet 'n Wild H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner

Wet 'n Wild H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner

Go on, cry. This eyeliner won't tell anyone.
3 star rating 3.004 reviews review it

 


Waterproof Eyeliner reviews


Best Fragrance Free Eyeliner


Wet 'n Wild Liquid Eyeliner

Wet 'n Wild Liquid Eyeliner

Wet and Wild H20 is the best liquid eyeliner on the market
4.5 star rating 4.405 reviews review it

 


Avon Daring Definition Gel Eyeliner


e.l.f. Studio Eyeliner and Shadow Stick


Fragrance Free Eyeliner reviews


Best Gel Eyeliner


Smashbox Jet Set Waterproof Eye Liner

Smashbox Jet Set Waterproof Eye Liner

SMASHBOX JET SET IS THE BEST I'VE TRIED
4 star rating 4.004 reviews review it

 


e.l.f. Studio Eyeliner and Shadow Stick


My Favorite Eyeliners - From Subtle to Dramatic!

My Favorite Eyeliners - From Subtle to Dramatic!

From subtle to dramatic, cheap to pricey, my favorite eyeliners!
5 star rating 5.001 review review it

 


Gel Eyeliner reviews



Browse by Type
Eye Concealer Eye Makeup Remover Eye Palette Eye Shimmer / Glimmer Eyebrow Pencil Eyelid primer Eyeshadow Fiber lash extention Mascara Remover base for eyes brush eyebrow color eyebrow grooming kit eyelash lengthener primer


Browse by Brand Name
Almay Avon Bare Escentuals Bare Minerals BeneFit Black Radiance Blinc Bobbi Brown Chanel Christian Dior Clinique Cover Girl CoverGirl Elizabeth Arden Estee Lauder EyeSense Jane L'Oreal Lancome MAC Make Up For Ever Mally Mary Kay Max Factor Maybelline Maybelline vs... Merle Norman My Favorite NYK Neutrogena New York Color PUR Minerals Paula's Choice Physicians Formula Pixi Prestige Cosmetics Revlon Rimmel London Sephora Smashbox Stila TIGI Tarte Too Faced Ulta Urban Decay Wet 'n Wild Yves Saint Laurent e.l.f. mark.


go to the eye makeup discussion board