Eyeliner Reviews

Trying to figure out which eyeliner is best for you? Can't decide between cake eyeliner and liquid eyeliner? Whether your look is classic, emo, goth or funky, read our eyeliner reviews to find the best liquid eyeliner, waterproof eyeliner, quick drying eyeliner, gel eyeliner and more.

Find out if MAC eyeliner is really better than Mary Kay eyeliner. Trying to decide between Cover Girl eyeliner, Avon eyeliner and Rimmel eyeliner? Let our members tell you which brand is their favorite.


results filtered by: remove all filters


Best Quick Drying Eyeliner

CoverGirl Line Exact Liquid Eyeliner

CoverGirl Line Exact Liquid Eyeliner

A quality and affordable liquid eyeliner by CoverGirl...




Wet 'n Wild Liquid Eyeliner

Wet 'n Wild Liquid Eyeliner

Wet and Wild H20 is the best liquid eyeliner on the market





Best Waterproof Eyeliner

Wet 'n Wild Liquid Eyeliner

Wet 'n Wild Liquid Eyeliner

Wet and Wild H20 is the best liquid eyeliner on the market



Smashbox Jet Set Waterproof Eye Liner

Smashbox Jet Set Waterproof Eye Liner

SMASHBOX JET SET IS THE BEST I'VE TRIED



Sephora Flashy Liners in Flashy Pink

Sephora Flashy Liners in Flashy Pink

To Look Wide Awake Try This Stuff!





Best Fragrance Free Eyeliner


Wet 'n Wild Liquid Eyeliner

Wet 'n Wild Liquid Eyeliner

Wet and Wild H20 is the best liquid eyeliner on the market






Best Gel Eyeliner

Smashbox Jet Set Waterproof Eye Liner

Smashbox Jet Set Waterproof Eye Liner

SMASHBOX JET SET IS THE BEST I'VE TRIED




Paula's Choice Constant Color Gel Eye Liner

Paula's Choice Constant Color Gel Eye Liner

Punctuate your Eyes with Constant Color