4.3
15 reviews
Other Eyeliners:
  • Average: 4.3
  • High: 5.0
Brand:
Almay
Almay Amazing Lasting 16 Hour Eye Pencil - All Shades

Read 15 Reviews

REVIEW SNAPSHOT®

by PowerReviews
Almay Amazing Lasting 16 Hour Eye Pencil - All Shades
 
4.3

(based on 15 reviews)

Ratings Distribution

  • 5 Stars

     

    (9)

  • 4 Stars

     

    (4)

  • 3 Stars

     

    (0)

  • 2 Stars

     

    (1)

  • 1 Stars

     

    (1)

87%

of respondents would recommend this to a friend.

Most Liked Positive Review

 

Water resistant means WATER RESISTANT!

This eyeliner is amazing. I usually prefer liquid eyeliners only because I've never found a pencil eyeliner that was worthy. I'd buy eyeliners with the slogan 'water proof', 'smudge proof' and...Read complete review

This eyeliner is amazing. I usually prefer liquid eyeliners only because I've never found a pencil eyeliner that was worthy. I'd buy eyeliners with the slogan 'water proof', 'smudge proof' and 'swear proof' which usually only turns to be a lie and a waste of my money. I had given up on even trying to find a pencil liners after so many failures and just stuck to my liquid one. A friend had recommended Almay to me so I gave it a fair shot and was mind blown. It really is all that the advertisements say. It doesn't smudge or smear and it's even waterproof. LOVE IT!

VS

Most Liked Negative Review

 

Amazing Lasting Eye Pencil doesn't last like it says it does

I really want to love this eyeliner, but I just can't. It doesn't do what it says, which is to last a long time. Pros: it glides on easily and the color...Read complete review

I really want to love this eyeliner, but I just can't. It doesn't do what it says, which is to last a long time. Pros: it glides on easily and the color is nice and rich. Cons: It slides down my face almost immediately, and I look like a raccoon. I don't know why eye make up doesn't seem to stick on me, but it doesn't, so I've turned to waterproof mascara and long-lasting eyeliners. This one is not worth the money: it reminds me very much of Avon's waterproof eyeliner, and I experienced the same no-stay power with that one, too. It's also a bit expensive, so I'd really expect it to perform better for the price. I suppose it seems to stay fairly well on my upper eyelids, but it does fade, and there's no way I get 18 hours of wear from it. The lower lids is where it really doesn't perform, so if you are like me and use eyeliner on both your upper and lower lids, I'd recommend trying another product. If you use it on just your upper lids, it may work for you. Ultimately, I'm just not satisfied with how it works.

Reviewed by 15 customers

Displaying reviews 1-10

Back to top

Previous | Next »

(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

 
4.0

This is the only eyeliner I use on my sensitive eyes.

By 

from USA

Comments about Almay Amazing Lasting 16 Hour Eye Pencil - All Shades:

I really like this product from Almay. It is the only eyeliner I use on my sensitive eyes. I like the colors (I usually use a dark brown). I have tried several other colors as well, and have been pleased with them all. My eyes are extremely sensitive and this product is the only one I use on my eyes. It works. I can usually leave this product on for upwards of about 10 hours before it starts bothering me. The only thing I would change is the staying power of the liner. It tends not to line if you have any lotion on your eyes. It also tends to come off a little too easily to me. I have to "secure" it in place by placing eye shadow over it to lengthen the time before it begins to come off. That being said, overall, this is my go-to liner and I would probably not even consider another product because of how well this product works with my sensitive eyes. Of course, that is my most important overall issue to address. On that note, Almay has the corner on the market.

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
5.0

Great!

By 

from Lake Providence, LA

Comments about Almay Amazing Lasting 16 Hour Eye Pencil - All Shades:

I purchased my daughter an Almay Eyeliner Pencil in black the other day. She has really been enjoying making up her face with it.Her eyes are so  much more attractive and luxurious now. She thanks me everyday for her gift.She wears it as often as she can to highlight her eyes and to show off her beautiful and attractive brown chestnut-like eyes. Before I purchased the Almay Eyeliner Pencil in black she use to go with anything on her eyes and they were okay but now that she uses the eyeliner pencil her eyes really popped out and stand out to you. I am so happy that a friend recommended that I buy her one because now she wears her eyeliner pencil all the time and her eyes just glow and shine as she goes out on the town or go shopping around town. I highly recommend that anyone who wants their eyes to pop out and stand out try the Almay Eyeliner Pencil in black too so they can get the experience of having their eyes shine too!

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

 
1.0

Didn't work for me...

By 

from Topeka, KS

Comments about Almay Amazing Lasting 16 Hour Eye Pencil - All Shades:

I've searched and searched and searched for an eye liner that will stay on my eye lid. It seems that my eye lids may just not be compatible with eye liner! I have tried them all. Long lasting from all the brands, the best reviewed and they have all failed me. This eye liner received great reviews and claimed to stay put for 16 hours. Two problems with this particular product: 1)it is nearly impossible to get on your eye lids. I felt like I had to put extreme pressure on my eye lids to get any color whatsoever on. This is an extremly sensitive area and should not be tugged on. So...I was not impressed by this. 2)Ten years later and after much pressure, the liner was finally on. However, it sure as heck did not stay put for 16 hours. Two hours in to wearing it...it was smudged on my upper eye lid. Ugh! So, it didn't work for me, but I know others that love it!

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
5.0

Outstanding!!!

By 

from Continental, OH

Comments about Almay Amazing Lasting 16 Hour Eye Pencil - All Shades:

I absolutley love this eye liner! I use this on an everyday basis. It is very legit when it says it lasts 16 hours! I can wear it all day, and its still there at the end of the day. It is waterproof as well, so if you are in those teary moments, or in the rain, you don't have to worry about it running off your face and looking like a mess. It stays in place. I first tried this when I had a problem with my eyes last year, I thought maybe I was allergic to my eyeliner. I don't know if that was really the problem, but now I wouldn't switch back. It is fairly reasonable in price, and I don't mind spending the money for the product. I would defiantly reccomend this to anyone, expecially if you are allergic to a lot of makeup.

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
2.0

Amazing Lasting Eye Pencil doesn't last like it says it does

By 

from Colorado Springs, CO

Comments about Almay Amazing Lasting 16 Hour Eye Pencil - All Shades:

I really want to love this eyeliner, but I just can't. It doesn't do what it says, which is to last a long time. Pros: it glides on easily and the color is nice and rich. Cons: It slides down my face almost immediately, and I look like a raccoon. I don't know why eye make up doesn't seem to stick on me, but it doesn't, so I've turned to waterproof mascara and long-lasting eyeliners. This one is not worth the money: it reminds me very much of Avon's waterproof eyeliner, and I experienced the same no-stay power with that one, too. It's also a bit expensive, so I'd really expect it to perform better for the price. I suppose it seems to stay fairly well on my upper eyelids, but it does fade, and there's no way I get 18 hours of wear from it. The lower lids is where it really doesn't perform, so if you are like me and use eyeliner on both your upper and lower lids, I'd recommend trying another product. If you use it on just your upper lids, it may work for you. Ultimately, I'm just not satisfied with how it works.

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
4.0

awesome eyeliner

By 

from San Antonio, TX

Comments about Almay Amazing Lasting 16 Hour Eye Pencil - All Shades:

This eyeliner is awesome i love it exept for one thing about it, it smears through out the day but that nothing you cant fix, i love the way the black looks it sort of has a little shine to it when i put it on. Its actually the eyeliner im using now and ive been using for a while and usually i change my eyeliners every 2 months or so.

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
5.0

I love, love, love Almay eyeliner!

By 

from Lexington, KY

Comments about Almay Amazing Lasting 16 Hour Eye Pencil - All Shades:

I rarely buy the same beauty product twice, but this is a product I keep coming back to. This is awesome eyeliner I have ever used before. It goes on easier than all other traditional liquid liner especially if you use a quality fine-tip brush and this is a product which actually lasts. Other cream or gel liners on the marke don't have this longevity. A few seconds after you glide it on, it dries and doesn't budge on yopur eyes. It also has a shiny finish which I never found in other products.So now you have more dramatic or retro look. I love this eye liner. I've had my "Bronze" gel liner for over 4 months and it hasn't dried out one bit (even after discovering I left the lid barely screwed on a few times). Stays on all day and doesn't fade. Easy to wash off. Excellent. I will be buying more colors. and yet it comes off fairly easily with makeup remover.It goes smooth while you apply, you can paint a thin line or a thick line. And it stays all day.I can go from 8hours of work and then go play 3 sets of tennis and still have this eyeliner on my eyes

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

(2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)

 
5.0

The Best Eyeliner EVER!

By 

from Undisclosed

Comments about Almay Amazing Lasting 16 Hour Eye Pencil - All Shades:

I've been wearing eyeliner for ages. And I've tried all the different brands trying to find one that works the way it is supposed too. Almay Eyeliner Pencil in Black is the answer to my prayers. At first it appears like any other pencil eyeliner, but according to the label Almay's is hypo-allergenic, which, even though I don't have issues, it's a plus. Applying this eyeliner is where I felt the difference. The pencil is firm yet apply's smoothly, and very rich in color. When applied it doesn't go all over, like some eyeliners, but exactly where I want it to go.

Throughout the day, the eyeliner doesn't lose any of it's color or smears at all. It stays exactly where I want it too! While this isn't a "*fun, or exciting"* eyeliner, it keeps me very happy by doing the job I expect it to do.

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

 
5.0

I am loving this eye liner product

By 

from Stopover, KY

Comments about Almay Amazing Lasting 16 Hour Eye Pencil - All Shades:

I truely love this product. The almay Eyeliner is awesome it glides on fast and easy to use and i am a single parent to a 2 year old and a 6 month old so time is very limited. Not only will it be fast and easy to put on, but all so it is long lasting and that is wonderful when i dont have to keep reapply it. I always put it on in the morning and it stays all day. It does cost all little more but i would rather pay that price and get a better product would'nt you I wear make up everyday i am one that wont leave home with out it on. you know I can be sick or dying and i am worried about my make up and looks... So i am always looking for new and better products. better quality better prices better in everything. It is all so water proof and it is natural. I dont know about you but I love the fact that i can just twist it and there my eyeliner is and i dont need to worry about a pencil sharpner. Because i am one that when i used the pencil sharpner i usually will do it to much and it breaks off or i mess it up some how you know how that works girls. So just give it a try and see what you think.

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
5.0

BEST, BEST, BEST Eyeliner out there!!!

By 

from Bakersville, NC

Comments about Almay Amazing Lasting 16 Hour Eye Pencil - All Shades:

This eyeliner is the best I have ever used. I have been wearing make-up for over 15 years and this is hands down the best eyeliner pencil I have used. There is no smearing and it stays on for hours...without smudges!!! It is a great product with a great price!!!

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

Displaying reviews 1-10

Back to top

Previous | Next »