Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress

Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress Reviews



Overall 3.5 star rating3.70 of 5 (by 74 users)



Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress Review Summary

Though the Simmons Beautyrest Pillow Top mattress gets pretty high marks, there were a few reviewers who were very unhappy with their purchase. Let’s start with the positives, shall we? Our reviewers reported that this Simmons Beautyrest mattress helped treat minor aches and pains in the back and hip areas. Some of our reviewers noted that this mattress absorbed the movements of their sleeping partners very well. Also a plus, the Simmons Beautyrest Pillow Top Mattress comes with a 10 year warranty. Here are the negatives; According to one review the company is hesitant to honor the aforementioned warranty. This was bad for Viewpoints reviewers who felt that the Simmons Beautyrest, while comfortable in the beginning, began to sag in the middle after about three years. As a result, some reviewers felt “ripped off”. Want to compare? Viewpoints has many more mattress ratings.
39% of people rated Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress as 5 stars
39% of people rated Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress as 5 stars%
39%
34% of people rated Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress as 4 stars
34% of people rated Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress as 4 stars%
34%
4% of people rated Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress as 3 stars
4% of people rated Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress as 3 stars%
4%
4% of people rated Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress as 2 stars
4% of people rated Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress as 2 stars%
4%
19% of people rated Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress as 1 star
19% of people rated Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress as 1 star%
19%
77% 77% of people recommend Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress 23% of people don't recommend Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress 23%
 

Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress Comparison

4 star rating Most Helpful
Favorable Review
DEC
21
2007

This was the first high quality mattress I ever purchased. It has set the standard for me, so I cannot tolerate anything less supportive. My first one had an unusual irregularity, but under warranty I had it replaced with no problems. My second mattress has been perfect. The design really does cut...

review »
appreciative of good customer service, a person who enjoys quality

Hostalover
Bethlehem, PA
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
1 star rating Most Helpful
Critical Review
FEB
23
2008
We have had this mattress for 3 years.  It was wonderful at first, but after about 1 year, it began to sink in the middle.  We compare our bed to sleeping in a bowl.  we are both in out early 30's and very active people.  However, we wake up with stiff backs and aches all over.  We recently stayed... review »
reviewer 2008 Contributor
too busy to make beds

minas-mom
Bel Alton, MD
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 

Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress Ratings and Reviews

items/page: 15 | 30 | 50 displaying 1 to 13 of 74 sort by: most helpful | date | rating


21
helpful
votes
interested in comfort, Mr. Fix-it

SEP
15
2008

We got this Simmons about a year and five months ago and when we first got it we were in heaven, After one year my wife started getting back aches I soon followed with back aches. We went on a 21 day cruise and our back aches were gone.. when we returned to our bed the back aches came back ! This was in May.  I called Simmons and they told me I have to call the store I bought it from. and the store would set me up for a "Mattress Inspector" to come out to my house but only if there were no rips, stains, or tears in it.  I got paper work to fill out and it told me to cut all of the Simmions...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
1 star rating
reviewer
liptont
Holbrook, MA



20
helpful
votes
interested in comfort

JUN
6
2008

I have arthritis in my back and hips and was looking to replace our old matress for something more comfortable.  We looked at regular beds, but I discovered that a firm pillowtop was more supportive.  We tried out a LOT and decided on this one, even though it was a bit pricier than we wanted to spend.

It started out just great, but now after about 6 months I have found that the pillowtop has seemed to crush down forming a depression that I keep rolling into during the night.  I wake up anywhere from 4-5am with my back hurting because of this.  I don't find that it supports me as well as when...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
2 star rating
reviewer 2008 Reviewer
cinnamon13
Kittanning, PA



9
helpful
votes
interested in comfort

DEC
28
2008
The mattress was heaven at first - then became a mushy bowl.  No matter how hard we try to sleep on the edge to avoid falling into the middle - we wake up stuck in the middle of the bed and have to crawl out.  Very disappointing for a Simmons - which I always wanted because of its reputation.  The mattress is 16 months old - and even looking at it after puting fresh sheets on - you can see that the mattress sinks to the middle.  Not worth the money.
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
1 star rating
reviewer
NeedComfort
Oostburg, WI



9
helpful
votes
practical, have back problems, a person who enjoys quality

NOV
21
2007
I would never buy this mattress nor would I ever recommend it to anyone.  It didn't hold up at all.  I had always thought this was a select mattress that people would buy over and over again but to my dismay, it wasn't.  I felt that I got ripped off because it didn't last more than 3 years and mattresses should stand up for many many years.
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
1 star rating
reviewer
sierramist
Bronx, NY



5
helpful
votes
interested in comfort, Mr. Fix-it

MAR
24
2009
I purchased this mattress 13 months ago at Sleepy's. It has what they call "eggs", which are basically holes that you fall into as if you were sleeping on a pullout couch or a terrible hotel room mattress. It has caused back pain for both my fiance and myself and was inspected and deemed DEFECTIVE. While Simmons is replacing the mattress, they are charging me $90 to deliver it and pick up the defective one. What? You mean, I am going to pay you to replace something that you sent me that was defective to begin with? OK. Fine. I will pay it this year. If the next mattress is defective next year do... review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
1 star rating
reviewer 2009 Contributor
hdubya1
Boston, MA



5
helpful
votes

MAR
14
2009
 

Rejoicing Pillow-Top from Mattress Discounters

 

The structure of this bed is hard on the sides, too soft in the middle.  So when my boyfriend and I were sleeping on it, he would end up on my side because he couldn't stay on the side, he was almost rolled in by the bed.  Plus, BeautyRest is just not made for stomach sleepers.  The picture shows someone on their side and the bed conforming.  Problem is, the bed goes down in those areas even when you're not on your side - so your body gets all contorted with your neck at an uncomfortable angle when on your stomach.  I had the same problem...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
1 star rating
reviewer 2009 Reviewer
reviewindc
Washington, DC



4
helpful
votes
Mr. Fix-it

MAR
9
2008
I paid way to much money for this horrible pillow top mattress.  Each side is now indented with my body.  I was told that the foam would never sag where you lay, but that was totally wrong.  When I called to ask about the warranty I was told that the mattress has to be 2 inches deep before they would do anything.
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
1 star rating
reviewer
gordonfan2411
Southfield, MI



3
helpful
votes
too busy to make beds, interested in comfort, picking up after pets, messy

MAR
3
2008
This is one of the best mattresses I've slept on. I suffer from back and neck pains, mainly due to spasms, and this mattress is so comfortable I hardly feel any pains when I wake up, unlike the others which eventually left me feeling achy all over. I love how the top is quiltlike, like laying down on little soft, yet firm, pillows. It's worth the price.
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
2008 Reviewer
morteamoureuse
Las Marias, PR



2
helpful
votes
practical, have back problems

MAR
20
2009

The  Beautyrest Pillowtop Bonita (Queen) developed a channel where I sleep within 2 weeks of purchase.  I am tall and average weight.  I went back to where I bought it but they did not offer a return or exchange.  ("Sorry about your problem".)  I recently talked with someone else who had the same experience with this mattress.  They lived it for 3 years before the indentation met the warranty requirments.  In addition, they had to pay to have someone come out and inspect the indentation (twice!) prior to the warranty being exercised.

I've had the mattress for 13 months and developed...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
1 star rating
reviewer 2009 Contributor
MAKAW
Addison, TX



2
helpful
votes
interested in comfort

JUL
9
2009

  Our Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress is 16 months old. For the first 10 months it was comfortable and I had no complaints. Around that time, my pelvic joints began aching, followed by my back and shoulders. I went to the Dr. and even had x-rays. Most of the aches went away when I got up. My body now hurts after about 10 minutes of lying on my side. Presently, I sleep on the very edge, where it is the firmest. Around 4 AM, when I wake up  with an aching back and hips, I go off to sleep in the spare bed room on an old, comfortable mattress. This Simmons mattress has a ridge down the middle(...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
1 star rating
reviewer
needssleep
Clarkston, MI



2
helpful
votes
appreciative of good customer service, value conscious, married, have back problems, expecting good, fair service, not rich, a homeowner, quality conscious

NOV
25
2007
The Simmons Grandeur pillow top mattress from Rooms to Go has been comfortable and durable. My wife and I did purchase the extended service plan which was a waste of money to me. I will not do that again for a mattress. The mattress has built in side handles that make it easier to move or to flip the mattress. The mattress is very heavy. After years of wear and tear, the mattress has lost it's firmness. All in all I would say that this mattress has been comfortable over the years and I am satisfied with it. It was very expensive in my opinion, but my wife and I were young and just starting out.... review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
3 star rating
reviewer
busybees4sale
New Port Richey, FL



1
helpful
vote
interested in comfort, picking up after pets

MAR
17
2008
My husband and I just purchased a Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Harmony model. We're very pleased with it. If you love firm mattresses,this is the one to get. We got it during a sale at Mattress Giant. (which included the boxpring and next day delivery for total 819.00.) I love that I can get out of bed and not even disturb my husbands sleep.
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
2008 Contributor
faeriekitty
Williamstown, NJ



1
helpful
vote
interested in comfort

MAY
5
2009

This bed ia a real great investment. There use to be days and nights when the energy just wasn"t there. We tried vitamin c,e,d. Then we tried sports drinks and enegy drinks for extra stamina. We tried more exercise. We tried yoga, walking, weights and even soccer. It seemed the more we did the less we enjoyed it after the first 1 or 2 weeks. Then Peggy suggested a different sleep system. We looked for price first. That was a real mistake. If you sleep 6 hour a night that is 1/4th of your like in bed. After looking  for a few weeks we checked out the Simmons Beautyrest. Once you relas inthe showroom...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
reviewer 2009 Contributor
kjkrphdawg
Warner Robins, GA



Reviews of Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress

1  2  3  …  5  
Buttons_next
 

Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress Discussions

displaying 2 of 2 discussions
displaying 1 to 2 of 2
Sticky sticky topic Locked locked topic New Posts new posts
Topic Author Views Replies Latest Post
D
Saggy pillow top
vetvet 24 2
OBX »
D
New Expensive Simmons Beautyrest soaking us literally
Rottweiler 40 0
Rottweiler »

Start a New Discussion about Simmons BeautyRest Pillowtop Mattress