Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Reviews

Not a magic cleaner, but close and it smells good

Overall

Rated 4 out of 5

I prefer green products, but you can't always get what you want in a cleaner that is mean and green.  I purchased the Mr. Clean Magic Eraser with Febreze and admit that it sat underneath my kitchen sink for far too long. 

What I like about the Mr. Clean Magic Eraser with Febreze: 

• easy to use 

• wears down to almost nothing so little trash 

• versatile - cleans a variety of surfaces 

• pleasant scent 

What I don't like about the Mr. Clean Magic Eraser with Febreze: 

• not "green" 

• chemicals can be hard on surfaces and skin 

• the scent wears off quickly 

The first job I tackled with my Mr. Clean Magic Eraser ...

Mr. Clean's over glorified sponge.

Overall

Rated 2 out of 5

Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is just a sponge with cleaner already in it. It does clean good but so does a regular sponge with some dollar store cleaner. I do not see what the big deal is about these things since they are more costly and do no last as long as a regular sponge. Maybe that is because they are smaller than most normal sponges. When it comes to cleaning supplies I generally do not go outside the Dollar Tree to buy anything but try stuff on occassion to see if it is worth the extra money. Mr. Clean Magic Erasers are not worth the extra money. Heck the old bucket with diluted bleach and sponge even works just as good and is also cheaper. If you like wasting money go ahead and buy these things but if you are looking to save some money use something else because you are not going to get your moneys worth out of these because unlike a regular sponge that can be used for several months you will be lucky that these things will still clean after one or two uses.

Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Erases my mistakes - my purses thank him!

Overall

Rated 4 out of 5

I've been using Mr. Clean Magic Eraser now ever since they came out. I use these cute little do-hickies all over my home and I find that they are NOT just for cleaning the 'typical'; they're great on my countertop and my enamail sinks, but I love them for so much more.

I also highly recommend Mr. Clean Magic Eraser for cleaning scuffs on floors or walls, pencil marks and even sometimes pen marks. You can even get the Mr. Clean Magic Eraser a little wet, use a dab of uncolored soap and rub out any muck or grime that you may have gotten on any of your cute handbags.

I've also used Mr. Clean Magic Eraser on smudges and toy scuffs that have suddenly appeared on my walls. I have noticed someti...

Erase away what your kids do to your furniture with Mr. Clean

Overall

Rated 5 out of 5

I was first introduced to the Mr. Clean Magic Eraser from some friends who swore by it. Somehow down the road I had received a sample to try it out (several years ago) and have continued to buy them ever since. Looking like a sponge, the Mr. Clean Magic Eraser has some magical combination of cleaning products. Simply wet the eraser through like you would a sponge and go after whatever tough stains your walls, floors, cupboards etc… might have.

The eraser lasts for quite a while. After you are done cleaning, you can rinse it out and it’s almost like new. As it wears out I simply trim off the sections that are no good anymore and keep cleaning. Definitely worth it for all those marks th...

How did we ever live without Mr. Clean Magic Erasers??

Overall

Rated 5 out of 5

I cannot imagine life without Mr. Clean Magic Erasers!!! The do a great job at removing so many marks, without damaging the surface. I have used them so many times and salvaged something thus saving my sanity and some money, too! They work well on walls, though if you use flat paint expect some to come off, too... But thankfully flat paint is excellent for touching up. I have used them on my kids' shoes, toys, the shower (great for soap scum and hard water stains!), scuffs on floors, and my personal favorite... to remove those little marks that you get on car bumpers and mirrors when you rub against things! My garage is old and SO narrow. It is not common, but sometimes the front bumper or s...

Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Mop: Handy for shiny tile floors

Overall

Rated 4 out of 5

We have shiny white ceramic tiles throughout the bottom floor of our South Florida home.  When they're clean and shiny they look spectacular.  But there's the rub, keeping them clean and shiny.  So, I'm always looking for something to help me get them and keep them that way.

A couple of years ago I tried out the Mr. Clean Magic Eraser.  It seemed to work superbly when I used it to clean small stubborn spots, but it clearly wasn't made to clean a whole floor.

But then one day while at the store I noticed the Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Mop.  It didn't take me more than a moment to decide to give it a try.

Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Mop

There seems to be various version...

Magic Erasers are MAGIC!

Overall

Rated 5 out of 5

OMG ever since I first purchased the magic eraser I have become a clean freak!! This little pad is so amazing...It cleans my tub with no effort at all and best of all I do not need to use any chemical...just a few wipes with this eraser and the grime is gone!...I use it in the bathttub, the sinks, the floor, the countertops and even the baseboards...it wipes away everything from soap scum to scuff marks on your floor...also handy for shining the stainless steel faucets and handles in the house...wipes water stains completely away. Another miracle I have discovered is removing that green grass stain from your shoes...or even scuff marks on your shoes...I am sure that whatever you want to clea...

Then I used these things and now I'm a believer!

Overall

Rated 4 out of 5

Let's face it, nobody will ever ask me for advice about housekeeping and usually this is not something I enthuse about but I can't help raving about Mr. Clean Magic Erasers!  In fact, I was so excited about my first purchase of them that I think I used up the whole box of eight pads in a day, just cleaning this and CLEANING that! 

They do a beautiful job on just about everything, especially kitchen appliances, but they really come into their own when used to wash painted walls and cabinet doors.  Truly, they clean like magic erasers which use water so efficiently that the problem of stuff dripping down and leaving streaks is easily resolved.

If I have one complaint, it would be that the pads seem to wear out quickly but other than that -- even though I'll never be enthusiastic about housekeeping -- I certainly am a believer in Mr. Clean Magic Eraser!

Mr Clean Magic Eraser is a pretty handy cleaning tool to have!

Overall

Rated 4 out of 5

Mr Clean Magic Eraser is, by far, one of the most versatile housecleaning products ever devised. So says my mom, who has been around long enough to be qualified to make such a sweeping statement. At the age of 81, she's seen cleaning products and techniques evolve; feather dusters have given way to Swifters, big bulky Electrolux vacuum cleaners have ceded closet space to Hoover uprights, and a variety of different cleaning rags and sponges have been replaced by Mr. Clean Magic Eraser. Let's face it. Even though keeping a home tidy, clean, and hygienic is time-consuming and sometimes unpleasant, it has to be done. There is always some appliance with set-in dirt, a bathroom floor with soap scu...

Leaves a film on everything

Overall

Rated 2 out of 5

I have tried the Mr. Clean Magic Eraser several times and I just do not like this product. It seems to leave a weird film over everything I have tried to use it on. I am an avide cleaner. I could drive myself nutser if I would let myself things never seem to be clean enough or stay clean for long around here. With three children and a man child to keep up with it can be quite overwhelming. So I had seen the commercials for the Mr. Clean Magic Erasers and thought it sounded like a fantastic product. I went out and bought a box and wanted to use them to scrub down my walls first and foremost. Well, it was a little messy. These things crumble and you have to get them damp first so if you scrub ...

Mr. Clean Magic Erasers really are magic!

Overall

Rated 4 out of 5

I was a little late to the Mr. Clean Magic Eraser craze, but now that I've used them, I'm really impressed! These little foam "sponges" really are magic!

Like everyone else, I would love to know how Mr. Clean Magic Erasers work. What's in them and how do they do the miracles that they do? I have two kids, so naturally, I wanted to FIRST use these on my walls since that's the main reason why I bought them. I had heard that they perform miracles, so I was really excited to see what all the hype was about.

Good as a Last Resort, but Not my Go-To Item

Overall

Rated 3 out of 5

I purchased a multi-pack of Mr. Clean Magic Erasers about six years ago, when they were a brand new concept.  These are the ones I'm still using.  I pull them out that rarely.  Therefore, allow me to first say, they may have changed how they're made in that time - but I'm not sure I, personally, would bet on that enough to go buy more.  Unless I found them for free, I probably wouldn't bother.

The first time I used these was in college.  I apparently got a little willy-nilly with my highlighter during a study session and left a small mark on my wall.  Thus, I pulled out the handy-dandy eraser hoping for "magic" - what I got was paint pulled off of my wall - ann...

Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is a life saver

Overall

Rated 5 out of 5

Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is the best lifesaver product on the market.  I cannot - I mean CANNOT - live without my Mr. Clean Magic Eraser.  This is the most amazing product out there.  You lightly wet it and then rub out any mark you can find.  I love that I can remove any mark on my walls, floors, and pretty much any other surface I can find with this product.  I have found that it can leave a bit of a rub chemical-like mark on the surface of what I have rubbed after I use it but I find if I keep a damp paper towel with me and wipe off where I have just cleaned the mark with the Mr. Clean Magic Eraser it takes care of that problem.  I have cleaned all the "mystery...

Mr. Clean Eraser Works!

Overall

Rated 5 out of 5

Mr. Clean Eraser pads are one of my favorite cleaners for tough jobs. The little pads are easy to use. Just run one under water and attack your surface. You don't need any other cleaners with them (and it is advised not to). I love using it in the kitchen on my countertops and on my appliances. I use it in the bathroom on my tub, sink and faucets. I have used it on my glass shower doors, but I wasn't impressed with it there.

I love using Mr. Clean Eraser pads outside. My plastic lawn chairs are white and look like new after using the pads. I also clean my bird baths with these pads. They are a wonder on getting them clean again. I even clean my aluminum storm doors with the pads an...

Mr. Clean Magic Eraser removes stains quick!

Overall

Rated 5 out of 5

Performance

Rated 5 out of 5

Scent

Rated 5 out of 5

I just love the Mr. Clean Magic Eraser.  I have tried it on a lot of different things, and it always works!  I have a porcelain kitchen sink, and it gets discolored very easily.  I just use the eraser, and it erases all the stains away, leaving a great clean white sink, instead of a discolored one.  I also use it in the bathtub for the bathtub ring.  It also wipes off dirty fingerprints from doors and handles.  I have also used it on my laminate floor, and on painted walls.  I do wish it was a little stronger because sometimes it does tend to fall apart when scrubbing.  I cut them in half for my dry erase board.  It wipes it clean in a jiffy!  I do not wet it for the erase board, and it works well.  I do wet it and squeeze it out for all of my other chores.  I do tend to go through them quickly.  I tried the ones with the blue scrubber on them, and I prefer the plain white ones.  It is nice to clean without using any cleaners or chemicals.