I did some research and I think that the Dad's cat food is a good quality cat food made by a good company. In addition, the price is right especially for big bags. The food is small crunchy pieces with almost no odor, definitely not an offensive odor. I did try for quite a while to feed my cats this food along with wet food and treats of other food, but over time I think they really came to hate this food. They did eat it at first, but after a couple of weeks thy would come running when I filled up their bowl, but then they reacted badly and I watched them spurn the cat food and actually back away from it like they really hated it. My cats are picky though, so I recommend you try this food, just don't buy a giant bag. They do sell a small bag of this food, I recommend you try that first and make sure the cats are still eating this food after a few weeks before you invest in a giant bag. Quality of Ingredients I've looked at the ingredients and the Dad's website and I really think this food is made with good quality ingredients.