I like the texture of the eyeliner when you line your eye. It's very creamy. I also like that there is a smudge applicator at the end of the pencil so you can smudge the lines for a deeper look. It smudges quite well. The first time I tried putting on this eyeliner I botched it up and my eyelid looked a mess. But then I used the smudger and lo and behold, I didn't look like I tried to line my eyelids half-drunk. I haven't sharpened the pencil yet, but because the texture of the point seems so soft, I'm afraid that I'll break the pencil. Someone told me that if this is the case, I should try to harden it first by putting it in the freezer, and then sharpening may be easier. I really like that's waterproof, though sometimes it's SO waterproof that it takes quite a bit of time to get it all off.

panegyris

New York, NY

I bought this in black. I wanted to get something waterproof so that it would not smear. It goes on smooth and thick. no need to try and put a ton on. The color is a very dark almost blue ish black. the consistency is oily and thick, it gunks up my bottom lashes and weighs them down. I love how dramatic it looks and the staying power it has. But I dont like the color or the consistency. When it comes time to take it off, you will need A LOT of waterproof makeup remover. the yucky oily kind is the only stuff that works to get it off. it takes me at least two small circular makeup pads per eye to get all of this gunk off! and after that I still wake up with makeup on my face!! Even though this stays so well, I dont like how I cant get it off. Also the color makes my makeup look funky and not matching. It also still gets a little runny on hot days or when im exercising. id rather have less eyeliner than have it stuck on there forever!

LB415

Tomales, CA