This product is just okay I suppose. It has a good pigmentation and looks good on your eyes. However, when you are lining your lower lid, or applying to your lowder water line if it touches your eyes at all [which it is runny, so it does] it stings your eyes a little bit. Also, pieces of it will 'flake' off into your eyes during the day which looks horrible, and also can damage, scratch, sting or even cut open your eyes. Not very hygenic or safe. However, i like the bottle and the brush is nice too. The consistency could be a little bit thicker, this is kind of runny. It dries fast though. And it lasts long a lot of the time, at least when it doesn't flake off it lasts long. It smudges if you touch it at all, so for people who have deep set eyes I'm sure it would transfer up onto the brow bone area. I don't have deep set eyes so it's not a problem for me but I know people who have deep set eyes and this is a problem. For the price, which is cheap, this is a good buy. It's an alright product, and I will still use it sometimes.