Well, I CAN get into his personality. He is funny and smart and hard-working and charismatic and simply delightful. Clay has come a long way since his American Idol days. That was five years ago, and he has moved on. Why do people only want to associate him with Idol? He is a spectacular live performer. Songs are much, much better when he sings them live. Don't tell me that no one here saw the Juke Box tour in 2005!! Plus, his run on Broadway in Spamalot was fantastic. He has wonderful comedic timing. I am certainly enjoying all of the songs on On My Way Here, since he is a great interpreter, but my choice of music for him is always the more traditional style, like his Christmas songs or the big power ballads. Others prefer more uptempo songs. The good part about it is that Clay can sing them all. I don't think the songs on this album sound anything like Measure of a Man. So I guess my question is this: what do you want him to sing? Build Me Up, Buttercup is a song from the 60s. Why would you want him to sing that? This particular CD is more thoughtful and inspirational, but I don't hear 'peaceful' at all. I do hear challenging and uplifting, however. That's the theme of it. He has been through a lot of difficulty in his life and has emerged as a stronger person. Haven't all of us seen some tough times? We call all relate to the lyrics on this album. That's what he's doing here, giving us all songs that make us feel and think. They are not lazy songs at all. Perhaps at another time he will make an album of just fun songs. One of the strengths of On My Way Here is that it shows his versatility. It has uptempo songs and contemplative songs and slow jazzy romantic melodies. I am confused about your statement about how he has avoided becoming a caricature of himself or why that would have been "easy" to do. I have never thought of Clay in that way at all.