I really do think that the foam sunless tanners work as well as the lotions. The foams are messier and they do not color my skin as nicely as the lotions do. I much prefer a gradual tan to this awful foam product. The Neutrogena Sun Fresh Sunless Foam seems like a good idea and that will work better, be easier to apply, and have a nice color. Unfortunately, I did not experience any of these things. The foam was messy and streaky and it was really hard to evenly apply it. I washed my hands after as well and they still got turned a weird orange-y color. Once it had absorbed (which felt like forever), the color had an orange tint and was not a healthy tan color that I am usually looking for. Also, just like many other self tanners, this product just smells bad. It smells like I had been laying in a tanning bed. I hate that smell so much. I only bought this product one time and I will not purchasing it again.