I'm giving this product a 10 not because I like it at all. I do not. It is way too much for my taste. However, if you like bold dramatic eye looks and you don't want to run around searching for a liner that will work then stop right now and go buy this. It gives off a bold line of color. The line is too bold and too thick for my taste (I purchased black and I'm as white as they come). I also have very small everything so this looked ridiculous on my eyes but you smokey eye fans will probably LOVE it. It has unbeatable color pigmentation. I was so impressed I actually walked around looking like vampira for a day.