This eyeliner was recommended to me by a friend, and since I haven't used any other liquid liner. Before using, know that you can't make many mistakes with this stuff and get away with it. It's similar to a temporary tattoo, except it takes much more scrubbing to get it off your eyelids. You have to wait for the product to dry before blinking because you could cause the eyeliner to leave an imprint on your eyelid crease. Other than the initial terror of making sure you get the line right, this eyeliner stays as long as you want. I've worn it on hot summer days and it hasn't moved an inch. And I have oily skin and eyelids, especially when I sweat in the summer :). As previously mentioned, it is difficult to scrub off and can flake if not removed correctly. While this eyeliner needs maintenance before and after wear, when you're wearing it you don't even realize it's on and can go through your day without worrying about smudging.

Anine

USA

I know most people love this eyeliner for its color, cost, and longevity. And I agree that all of these latter factors are true. However, I'm not the biggest fan of this eyeliner. For some reason, this liquid liner burns my eyelids (I've never experienced this with any other liquid eyeliner). Oh well. It went into my trashcan. But for those of you who share the same dilemma as me and who want a cheap eyeliner, I highly recommend the Jordana liquid liner. It's the same price and has the same awesome longevity and color pay-off.

wattatta47

USA

didnt really like this liquid eyeliner. What i didnt like was that when i would put it on my top lid it would spread and reach almost my eyebrow and it was so hard to get off because it would dry up.And it really gets into your eye very easily and your eyes will get very i mean very blurry which ca real damage your eye sight so be careful with this eyeliner.

yeseniadmartinez

Oak Lawn, IL

There are several postitive attributes to WetnWild's waterproof eyeliner. It is brush-on, it stays on without running, and it affordable. I was told back in high school that paint-on eyeliner is essential for older women hoping to look young and freah eyed. Apparently, the pull of the pencil contributes to crows feet. While I am not "old", the only lines I want around my eyes are those I earn from laughing or spending too much time at the beach. Paint-on eyeliner won't damage tender skin and allows artistic freedom---if you want a Nefertiti look or a complete inside-the-lash line, paint-on liner allows this. The waterproof seems to be correct. I have worn the product for months and it comes off only in my makeup removing towelettes.I think I have cried it off before,though, so if you are a bit of a drama queen/emotional-outburst-haver, check your makeup after a good cathartic cry. :) Cheap is always doable with WetNWild. Drugstores often do BOGO or similar promotions and the regular price is affordable,too.

rebuiltbeauty

Williston, VT

I've been using liquid eyeliner since at least freshman year of high school, and been through my fair share of brands like Maybelline, Revlon, etc. Though I don't have major complaints against most of those products, I didn't have particularly remarkable things to say about them - they were definitely better than pencil eyeliner in terms of smudging, but they would flake sometimes, or generally just wear away over the course of a day. Not so with Wet n Wild eyeliner. I tried it out first because I was looking for something more affordable than the Maybelline eyeliner I was then using, and also because the black-brown shade available appealed to me (I'm Chinese American and straight-up black sometimes can be too harsh of a color for my eyelashes/eyes). I was amazed at the end of the day to discover that not only had it clung to my lids through my contacts-wearing, occasional eye-rubbing, and the shower I had taken, it was actually almost difficult to remove!

kachang620

Roswell, GA

OK - I admit it.  Hallmark commercials make me cry.  At a certain time of the month - almost everything makes me cry.  That is what makes the Wet and Wild H2O proof Liquid Eyeliner so great.  It doesn't run.  You can have a good cry (and what woman doesn't need a good cry once in a while although men don't understand) and not have to worry about your eyeliner making you look like a bank robber or raccoon.  I love the brush applicator - it makes a finer line than the felt tip style - although I must admit sometimes it does get on my eyelashes.  But all in all, I am very happy with the waterproof eyeliner.  Especially love the price.  Some of the other brands can get very pricey.  And with all of the other make up (eyeshadow, mascara, primer) - who needs most cost?  I say if you find a quality product for a lot cheaper - go for it.  This is it - it works great and lasts until you decide to remove it.

tmac0304

Julian, NC

I'm still looking for the perfect eyeliner. This is perfect for swimming and cry, it doesn't smudge, but it's hard to take it off, the only product that help you to clean your eyes from it, it's the same brand makeup remover. It's hard to apply it, because of the felt tip.

armycg

Long Beach, CA

I bought the **Wet 'n Wild H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner** precisely because I thought a felt tip marker would give me better control than a slippery brush or a smeary pencil.  Although the product has some flaws, for the most part, I'm sold on it. **The Formula**: - *Long-wearing* - It stayed on all day without smudging.  In fact, it stayed on until I removed it with eye makeup remover. - *Texture* - I prefer a liquid formula over a dry or chalky texture, so this smooth liquid eyeliner fit the bill. - *Comfort *- My eyelids can become sensitive to some brands of eye makeup, but Wet 'n Wild H2O proof eyeliner didn't cause any discomfort or adverse reactions. **Application:** - *Ease of Use* - This is where Wet 'n Wild lost a few points for me.  The felt tip applicator sounds good in theory, but I really had to practice to get the thin, smooth line that I was going for.  My first try left me with a huge wet stripe across my eyelid.  The trick seems to be the angle that I hold the brush tip.   I couldn't really get the "ultra-fine line" described on the package, but I did get a nice semi-fine line once I got the hang of it. - *Felt-tip Brush* - The felt-tip brush is surprisingly hard.  For that reason, it pays to apply the eyeliner lightly.  It won't matter how nice your makeup is if you poke your eye out. **Final Thoughts:** For an inexpensive, drugstore product, **Wet 'n Wild H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner** is a good buy.  The silky, waterproof liquid didn't irritate and I loved framing my eyes with deep black-brown color.  I'll definitely buy this again.

LoveisJoy

Chicagoland, IL