There will be no need for us to continue the search. Virbac CET Enzymatic Toothpaste in Vanilla Mint is the only toothpaste that has made the tooth brushing chore much more tolerable. Our dog loves the flavor but is still learning to love the toothbrush. We brush once a week while supplementing with Virbac CET Hextra Chews or Virbac CET Enzymatic Chews every other day. The combination has shown great results with sparkly white teeth and nice clean gums. Additionally, the scent is pleasant with no overbearing meaty, food odors. We find the best and only time to brush is right before the pup falls asleep. A little less energy makes a whole world of difference. So far, we have been really happy with the effectiveness of the Virbac CET Oral Hygeine line. I have and will continue to recommend these products to other fellow dog pamperers. You will find these retail at varying prices so search online for the best deal. Quality of Ingredients Doggie approved flavor! Side Effects No side effects.