I really like the Room Essentials 4-tier Accessory Shelf. I have one of these in my closet right now and one by the front door. They have lasted us for years and are still standing strong. After all that time they are both still in one piece. The only thing that has happened to these are a couple bend/bumps in it. They hold shoes very well. I didn't think that I would like that the top shelf would be smaller at first, but it ended up being the perfect size for little kid shoes. The rest of the shelves are perfect for any size shoes. We even like to slide flip flops and umbrellas under it for added storage space. It is pretty tall, but will still fit perfectly in a closet. It's easy to pick up and move around by the handles if you want to vacuum around it also. It's lightweight and portable. This is super easy to put together and will last you for years. I would buy this product again. The only thing that I would probably change is the style. It's not the most attractive shelf for by the front door, but if it's in a closet it's great!