I tried this with eye makeup and was not impressed. You are supposed to press it on top of your eye and wipe the eye makeup off. I found that even after wiping multiple times, the eye makeup was not completely removed. It did an okay job with eyeliners but with mascara, I had to use other makeup remover to get the mascara completely off. I would only recommend this product for people that only use eyeliners. If you use mascara, I don't think this will get the mascara off completely. Effectiveness This is not the most effective makeup remover. It may be easier to use but not as strong as the normal liquid type removers. It also dries up after opening so you would have to use it up quickly after you open the package and start using the first one. Ease of Use I bought this because I thought it would be easier to use than the normal oil type makeup removers. It is indeed easier to use but also less effective.