I absolutely love Neutrogena's Nourishing eye liner. I use to get whatever was cheap, but if this on sale is a bargain. It goes on perfect, and with the built in sharpener and the rubber smudger it looks perfect every time. I've even had issues with other brands causing me to break out around my eyes, not this product! I use the smudger every time and it gives that perfectly smooth look. I definitely recommend this product.