I put this at about a 70% overall. It's not bad, it's not that great either. The waterproof part is helpful but all in all it's just a bit too gritty and sloppy to get a higher rate. Performance Just about satisfactory performance when all is said and done. Mary Kay has other products that are far superior and I was a bit surprised at how sloppy this mascara was overall. It glops and slops a little and lacks that smoothness I was looking for. Ease of Application You have to be vigilant with it, otherwise you're going to end up clumping or bumping from lash to lash. The handle makes it hard to be graceful and the bristles aren't the kind of quality I was expecting.