I'm a liquid liner kind of girl, but after discovering MAC's kohl eyeliner, I always have to have it in stock. I know it's a bit pricey, but it lasts me awhile and never fails me. I can smudge it on with no tugging, and it provides a rich consistent color every time. I don't have to sharpen it often and I never have the issue of undereye makeup smudge; it seems to know to stay right in place! I have a 60's eye makeup sort of thing going on, so this works great for undereye lining but also doubles when I don't feel like waiting for my liquid liner to dry. Invest in this wonderful product!

MondoTeeno

Marietta, GA

I was surprised to see that no one has reviewed this product, I am in love with MAC eyeliner. It stays on most of the day if not all day and it goes on very easily. They have an array of colors which is pretty cool, but I generally stick to the darker colors. I like their stubborn brown and their engraved eyeliner colors. ;] 

kingbaby1032

Sunnyvale, CA

I love this eyeliner when I want something dramatic. It goes on smoothly and evenly. You can smudge it and/or set it with eyeshadow. Just be sure you only use a MAC sharpener because anything else will eat your eyepencil alive!

MsKush

Santa Barbara, CA