I bought Fresh mascara as a treat for myself one day. I wanted an expensive mascara to wear to a wedding that I was going to. I was really excited to try it because the girl in the store told me it was a top seller and worked great. I was very disappointed with it when I used it. It came out very dry and went on clumpy. It did NOT layer well and I actually had to wash my face and start all over because it looked so bad. I have tried it on a few more occasions, It was expensive so I had to try :), and found the same thng to be true. I also like really black mascara and this mascara looked almost grey. The bottle it comes in is very cute and I think this may attract many buyers, but beware because the product inside is very poor. The bottle is small and expensive and frankly does not work. I would never recommend this product to a friend and hope that you will make a better choice when treating yourself to some nice makeup!