I really wanted to like Bare Escentuals RareMinerals Renew & Reveal Facial Cleanser, but this product was subpar. I am a loyal Bare Minerals makeup customer and began trying their other products in their line, unfortunately, was disappointed in this product. The idea of going from a solid and mixing with water to create a lather was interesting, I liked how it smelled and how it felt on my face, but I never felt like it was really getting my face clean. Remember, I am a loyal Bare Minerals makeup user so I expected that the facial cleanser should be able to take their own makeup off. After I washed my face I would find makeup (usually quite a bit) on the towel I used to dry my face. I stuck with the product for a while, probably longer than I should have (probably because of the cost of the product), and just was never satisfied. Unfortunately, I would not recommend this product unless they changed the formula. I will be sticking to the Bare Minerals makeup line.