While I think this product is more on the expensive side for the amount you get, it is a pretty good product. The shade I buy is black. The pigment is great, very bold and long lasting. However, that's provided you stay clear of water. I've found that the liner begins to run immediately if it gets a little wet. This is great as it makes cleanup pretty easy, but not so much if you're in the rain or, god forbid, you shed a few tears. In short, this product is not at all water proof. As I said before, cleanup is pretty easy. The majority of it comes off with a wet cloth, though you'll likely have to use a little soap to get it off completely. While the makeup is not overly-runny, it can be a little hard to apply. I usually use a wet q-tip to clean up the lines. The foam brush is nice, but it's hard to get a clear, straight line. Especially after a few uses when the "brush" begins to fray. While you can simply pull or cut off those stray pieces, it's a recurring problem.