Discussion Categories

smblomker Newark, OH posts: 30
2009 Writer
posted on October 26, 2009 at 10:52PM Inappropriate? Quote Reply

If God created heaven and the earth, who created God?

2009 Advisor
posted on October 28, 2009 at 11:41AM
 

Faith is an extension of what we do constantly--though you may not call it faith.  I'm typing away on my keyboard, I have the faith and belief that the buttons will work, the process will result in a communication, my brain will talk to my fingers and so on and so forth.

When I think of something, I have to believe I can do it.  If I decide I can gather together some people and put on a reading even though I can't offer money and don't know who will show up....I have to have faith that it can and will be done even though there are so many factors that could stop it from happening and so many factors that will not make it a success.

A pure faith isn't a means to an end however.  It just is something you have decided to believe.  God, another concept, yourself, a loved one.

Trust and faith are interconnected aren't they? 

2009 Advisor
posted on October 28, 2009 at 11:56AM
 

Trust and faith CAN be interconnected: I have faith that this chair will hold me, or I trust that this chair will hold me.

I think faith can also imply a hope in things not yet seen that the word trust doesn't quite convey.

2009 Writer
posted on October 28, 2009 at 12:04PM
 
In response to TheBard's post from October 28 2009 11:19AM
TheBard said…

 how could one being have amassed so much power?           

 


 That's really a beautiful sentence. One day you and I will wake up and suddenly know the answer to this. Keep asking yourself the question.


 

 Moderator
posted on October 28, 2009 at 12:24PM
 
In response to rustaddsflavor's post from October 28 2009 12:04PM
rustaddsflavor said…
TheBard said…

 how could one being have amassed so much power?           

 


 That's really a beautiful sentence. One day you and I will wake up and suddenly know the answer to this. Keep asking yourself the question.


I don't beleive I will... 


 

2009 VIP
posted on October 28, 2009 at 12:31PM
 
In response to onwaytozion's post from October 28 2009 09:38AM
onwaytozion said…
AnnaBanana said…


You must have missed that long-winded, antagonistic discussions thread not too long ago about "Abortion" which ended up being an absolute disgrace and an embarrassment to the ViewPoints forum, in my opinion.

That's what I meant about sensitive subjects escalating wildly.  If you want to say what you think about God, that's fine, but it would behoove us all to be courteous and respectful of others when we are voicing our personal opinions.


You're right AnnaBanana, I didn't see the abortion thread.

I'm just sad that we can talk freely, wear clothes, and decorate our cars with sports team logos and rock band images but when we do the same concerning God, we are labeled "Jesus freaks" and avoided. Isn't our savior more important than a sports team?

I know, some people think it's disrespectful to mention God in such a "tacky" way. But I want to praise Him in any and all ways!

I don't mean to be disrespectful to anyone. But I don't want to be disrespected either!

 


The thing about talking about religion is that it can start out politely and probably stay polite until specific belief systems/religions are mentioned.  So far, the topic is safe because everyone seems to be on the same theological page.

I hope it stays friendly and civil, but my grandfather, who was a devout Catholic, once gave me this bit of sage advice: "Never get into discussions about religion in public."

 

 Moderator
posted on October 28, 2009 at 12:34PM
 
In response to ChrisJarmick's post from October 28 2009 11:41AM
ChrisJarmick said…

Faith is an extension of what we do constantly--though you may not call it faith.  I'm typing away on my keyboard, I have the faith and belief that the buttons will work, the process will result in a communication, my brain will talk to my fingers and so on and so forth.

When I think of something, I have to believe I can do it.  If I decide I can gather together some people and put on a reading even though I can't offer money and don't know who will show up....I have to have faith that it can and will be done even though there are so many factors that could stop it from happening and so many factors that will not make it a success.

A pure faith isn't a means to an end however.  It just is something you have decided to believe.  God, another concept, yourself, a loved one.

Trust and faith are interconnected aren't they? 


It's fine to have (trust) and faith in a Devine Being, but I ask again, to what end?  And if "pure faith" isn't a means to an end, then what is the point to the belief?  Why decide to believe in God in the first place?  Just because?     

 

2009 Advisor
posted on October 28, 2009 at 12:51PM
 

A lot has been written about this.  

You open yourself to something larger, a compassionate higher power of your own (God, Goddess, love, or something nameless that you don't necessarily define at all).  When you do this, you gain strength.  You know you are not alone. 

You put distance between yourself and something negative to view it from a higher ground--get out from yourself.   The Buddhists call it your monkey mind which creates a small insular cycle that you can't break out of so you realize there's something greater than the emotion of the moment.  You stop hurting others and yourself and seek to become more expanded.

Emotions play very specifically on each of us.  A great example of this is jealousy.  A bitter jealousy plays on self-esteem which cycles downward into depression and hopelessness.  

So you want to cycle upward with a higher purpose.  GOD could be seen as a catch-all phrase meaning many things.   Your higher purpose might be love... not of yourself.. but of say your family.   That you bellieve is a higher purpose.

This gives you a higher purpose.  A bellieve in a higher purpose is important to maintaining your sanity.

You may not need GOD but we must have a way to get over ourselves and away from the downward cycle.. any downward cycle.

Some decide that things they can't quite explain with logical thinking is the work of GOD.  Intuition is from God, many believe.

Meditation and prayer is important and it has been proven through real world measurments of the brain that changes occur through meditation and prayer.

You don't have to believe in any God, but there are other things that happen that can't be explained in any conventional sense.  God is an easy explanation perhaps and certainly an illogical one.

Some sense of and use of spirituality actually affects the brain and mind, transporting us to another place.

There is no downside to this.  You elevate yourself and your thinking, come at a problem or a depression from a different place.

Hope that gives you something to chew on, think about it, consider.

2009 Writer
posted on October 28, 2009 at 01:00PM
 
In response to TheBard's post from October 28 2009 12:34PM
TheBard said…


It's fine to have (trust) and faith in a Devine Being, but I ask again, to what end?  And if "pure faith" isn't a means to an end, then what is the point to the belief?  Why decide to believe in God in the first place?  Just because?     

 


I personally find it mentally pleasing to think that there is a God, even though I'm a deist. I went through a harsh realization once that all of my fervent prayers were not going anywhere and totally lost faith. Then I started pondering how "something" came from "nothing" and, while contemplating the impossible complexity of physical life, taking nothing for granted (such as DNA being the answer to how a living being takes shape), I eventually came to believe that there has to be some guidance going on behind the scenes. Nature itself would never have bothered to form gases (again, from nothing), explode them, let them cool into planets with a very convenient - thoroughly accidental - central star/sun, then slowly but surely bring forth a myriad of life forms.

There were some critical challenges I simply could not find a scientific answer for, such as:

How does DNA know what to do with the matter it attaches?

How does it seperate useful matter from useless matter? How does it KNOW to?

Where did that matter come from?

How did an entire universe filled with countless planets and stars form from what - logically - had to have been zero matter and zero space?

I'm not trying to convince you there's a God, and I certainly don't think there's a God the way we think of "Him", in human form, bearded, white robe, speaking in a deep, profound voice, kind of ticked-off, etc.. But I do think that the very existence of ANYTHING defies simple logic and I find some sense of divine guidance necessary at the end of the day.

So, TheBard, having said all that, I still don't think believing in God is of any real meaningful equity. Beyond its ability to please us, which does carry equity. And I think we should recognize and give credit for being here. We certainly didn't have to be at all.

Will you fly away to Heaven after your body can't be bothered with you any more? I doubt it. That's where my faith ends, and I have no problem with that. Afterall, I've not been here for billions of years longer than the few I'll have been here. It never seemed to have bothered me any.   

I don't look at "God" as a reflection of my divine, omnipotent Entity, rather as a force that exists on a far different realm and which, tired of looking out and seeing nothing for so long, naturally felt compelled to put something there.

 Moderator
posted on October 28, 2009 at 02:08PM
 

Chris-

Very well put.  I agree with you insofar as needing and even benefiting from believe in something larger than self.  For me it is taking care of my family, being a provider, being a man my children (all girls) can look up to and use as an example of the kind of man they want to attract.  That for me is enough to fulfill my life.   As you allude to, we all must find this higher plane for ourselves, and it appears as though you have!

Rustaddsflavor-

Also well put.   Very valid points.  For the longest time I held on to my (fading) belief in the God of religion, then later in life realized that such a being didn't really exist, because my logical mind would allow for it.  Now that does not preclude my belief in a force, Mother Nature perhaps, that could and probably does explain the enormous diversity and complexity of life on this planet, and most likely throughout the universe.  

But the One God of religious incarnation is dead for me; he was a mere creation of man's fertile searching, ignorant mind, much as Oden, Hercules, Zeus, Ra, Venus, Loki, Athena, Horus, Poseidon, Atlas, Romulus, Remus, Hades, and the countless other Gods and Goddesses were before the One God ruled them all!.

Vincent          

2009 Advisor
posted on October 28, 2009 at 02:32PM
 

Yes, Vincent, your love of your family giving you that higher sense of value is not in the strictest term logical and it has no finite, easy to quantify and break down worth in terms of things we can touch.    That's the things that is--for you and I would hope many others of great value, and importance.   You can give many reasons why this sense of family is in you but after all the questions are thrown at you it still comes to... that's the way it is.  That is who you are and who you will always be--you won't be questioning it.

I too have this strong bond with family (and have 3 daughters also).

Someone might say you don't HAVE to be this way...nobody is actually forcing you to bbe this way  and many are not this way.

Of course you absolutely HAVE to be this way, it is the most important thing to you, this is beyond regular logical thinking and thought.  You need to sacrifice for them, you do it.  Period.

Much easier to grasp doing this for family then for some unknown to be sure.

And for some they believe, perhaps need to believe this type of devotion to family, particularly in its purest most selfless area is part of HIs/Her(GOD) plan.  The faith and belief in that higher power gives them strength, focus, confidence and if you have teenagers you can use all the help you can get (God only knows).   (yes, that's meant a bit flippantly).

 

You don't need to believe that something else gives you this... just your family values are in and of themselves enough of a purpose to keep your eye on the ball (so to speak).

Ah what a wonderful world it would be were everyone capable of such devotion to family.  So many 'problems' would  dissolve.

2009 Writer
posted on October 28, 2009 at 03:10PM
 

So now we've uncovered the meaning of life (family) AND proven we can discuss sensitive subjects without resorting to crude verbal assaults against each other.

Sounds like evolution is alive and well, afterall. I didn't even get the chance to say, "Damn Cadillac drivers think they rule the world."

WTF

2009 Advisor
posted on October 28, 2009 at 03:18PM
 

You actually did just get to say that!!!   Course for all their arrogance.. Cadillac is on life support.....

Now how about seat kickers and cell phone texters in movie theaters.. grrrr..

 

2009 Writer
posted on October 28, 2009 at 03:25PM
 

Hmmm, the human race with all its deverse ideas and concepts about belief and faith, well, I lost faith when it came to God when I was a kid, Seeing the things that people in this world have done to others just in the name of faith hasn't changed my ideas of God being all powerful. I asked someone once, if God was so powerful why does he let bad things happen and ended up answering my own question later on when I didn't like what that person said.

Its said that there can't be suffering without have compassion, I wonder, where is the compassion that were all surposed to have.

I think the power of God comes from people themselves. We choose our own roads to walk down and many of those roads aren't the best. When go to church because were taught when we were younger that we need too. We need to be socal creatures. We need to learn and teach, but, have we forgot to listen?

When it comes to God for me, He's not in my heart any more, Because I told him I didn't love him any more. I am saying this, because its time to close this discussion out before it gets carried away. I shouldn't started it and I'm sorry I even said anything now. Religion is a very touchy subject. People will never agree or disagree to agree. LOL...But, I got what i wanted from this. I'll start a discussion sometime that isn't so conterversey.

Thank you all for the hits.......Have a good day.

2009 Advisor
posted on November 01, 2009 at 05:24AM
 
In response to AnnaBanana's post from October 27 2009 08:29AM
AnnaBanana said…

It's okay if you just can't believe there is a God.  Faith is a gift, not a conscious decision. 

 


Every time I see a tree in bloom, or a bird chirping, or a rainbow...I thank God.  Who else could've CREATED all of this?  Remember - as journalist Ernie Pyle stated, "There are no atheists in foxholes."  Get yourself into a stressful situation, such as war...you'll start praying real quick.

2009 Advisor
posted on November 01, 2009 at 05:48AM
 

True OldHippie, true ~ and I have told my mother that saying, "there are no Athiests on their deathbeds".

Actually, smblomker ~ my mother would agree with you.  You are entitled to feel that way. 

Here's my little opinion ~ "God" is "Dog" spelled barkwards for a reason and vice versa.

2009 VIP
posted on November 01, 2009 at 07:26AM
 
In response to OldHippie's post from November 01 2009 05:24AM
OldHippie said…
AnnaBanana said…

It's okay if you just can't believe there is a God.  Faith is a gift, not a conscious decision. 

 


Every time I see a tree in bloom, or a bird chirping, or a rainbow...I thank God.  Who else could've CREATED all of this?  Remember - as journalist Ernie Pyle stated, "There are no atheists in foxholes."  Get yourself into a stressful situation, such as war...you'll start praying real quick.


Thanks, Buddy!  I feel the way you do but I am grateful for that faith.  Not everyone apparently is able to believe and life is not easy for someone like that.

 

 Moderator
posted on November 01, 2009 at 10:09AM
 
In response to OldHippie's post from November 01 2009 05:24AM
OldHippie said…
AnnaBanana said…

It's okay if you just can't believe there is a God.  Faith is a gift, not a conscious decision. 

 


Every time I see a tree in bloom, or a bird chirping, or a rainbow...I thank God.  Who else could've CREATED all of this?  Remember - as journalist Ernie Pyle stated, "There are no atheists in foxholes."  Get yourself into a stressful situation, such as war...you'll start praying real quick.


I reject that notion wholesale, because it espouses the notion that disbelieve in God is cursory and convenient; my decision was neither.  I have been is situation on a submarine akin to being fired at in a "foxhole" and I did not prey, I did not utter God's name even though death had come calling. 

Just because WE don't completely understand the beginnings of life doesn't mean that it was engineered by some all knowing, all powerful being invented in the mind of ancient man.  The Theory of Evolution points us in another more plausible explanation for the chirping bids, blooming trees, and flowing seas.

2008 VIP
posted on November 01, 2009 at 07:12PM
 

I have enjoyed reading the posts in this thread. I have especially enjoyed reading the many varied thoughts and feelings and I have appreciated the fact that most of the posts have been cordial and respectful of others. I agree with AnnaBanana that faith is a gift. Some people have tremendous faith insomuch that their faith has become unshakable. Others are still experimenting with faith.

Personally, I have always believed in a Heavenly Father. I think I was born believing. That belief has given my life meaning, purpose and direction. It has helped define who I am, what I stand for and where I place my trust. It has made me a better person, a better daughter, a better Mother, wife and friend.

I realize that someone who does not believe in the Lord can not begin to understand it. I get that, but I have had too many experiences in my life that reinforce my faith and beliefs to ever deny them. That said, I know that God exists. I have let him in to my heart and in to my life. Do I know who created him? No. Does that matter to my faith and belief in Him? No. I have the faith that one day I will know and understand. In the meantime, I am content to know that He is there if ever I need him.

2009 VIP
posted on November 01, 2009 at 09:00PM
 
In response to Meri's post from November 01 2009 07:12PM
Meri said…

I have enjoyed reading the posts in this thread. I have especially enjoyed reading the many varied thoughts and feelings and I have appreciated the fact that most of the posts have been cordial and respectful of others. I agree with AnnaBanana that faith is a gift. Some people have tremendous faith insomuch that their faith has become unshakable. Others are still experimenting with faith.

Personally, I have always believed in a Heavenly Father. I think I was born believing. That belief has given my life meaning, purpose and direction. It has helped define who I am, what I stand for and where I place my trust. It has made me a better person, a better daughter, a better Mother, wife and friend.

I realize that someone who does not believe in the Lord can not begin to understand it. I get that, but I have had too many experiences in my life that reinforce my faith and beliefs to ever deny them. That said, I know that God exists. I have let him in to my heart and in to my life. Do I know who created him? No. Does that matter to my faith and belief in Him? No. I have the faith that one day I will know and understand. In the meantime, I am content to know that He is there if ever I need him.


I could not have said it any better. I really do think that faith is either there or it isn't. I come from a religious mother and a very non religious father. I have every reason NOT to believe God exists after seeing what happened to my poor mother and later, my father. But my faith was never shaken. It wasn't because anyone taught me this because they didn't. I was never pushed into any religion and, indeed, heard all the reasons why I shouldn't believe from my father. They did make sense. But still, my faith remained and I know it always will.

I don't want to make others believe. You either do or you don't. I respect everyone regardless of their religious beliefs and am just content knowing I have someone to turn to in my darkest hour. If, in the end I was wrong, faith made my life better and more comforting so there were no negatives to my beliefs.

2009 Advisor
posted on November 03, 2009 at 12:00PM
 
In response to PattyTherre's post from October 27 2009 06:40PM

Starting two on the same topic would be called "abusing the system" and should have pts deducted :)

PattyTherre said…

You get 10 points for starting a discussion. I think starting two on the same topic is unnecessary.


 

2009 Writer
posted on November 08, 2009 at 10:59AM
 

They had took the other one off. so, this is the only one left.

posted on November 08, 2009 at 12:25PM
 

If you like to read there is an author, Lee Strobel who wrote many books on this subject, including The Case for a Creator. He is an athiest turned Christian. He originally started out to disprove Chrstianity. He has a website. leestrobel.com. His books have now been around long enough that you can probably get used ones for a good price.

2009 VIP
posted on November 08, 2009 at 01:18PM
 

I've been looking at this discussion thread again and I must say that I am impressed.  I think it ended up being pretty civilized, well thought out and respectful.  I respect everyone's intelligent point of view when it comes to this subject.  We each have an opinion about whether there is a God or not and what is going to happen after we pass through the curtain at the end of our mortal existence here. 

As I've said before (perhaps on the OTHER God thread), the reality of what comes next has already been in place for billions of years and does not depend on what we expect it to be.  What it boils down to is that we are free to think and believe sincerely whatever we want even though when this mortal life is over, some of us may be in for a big surprise. 

My fellow ViewPointers, I salute you!  Well done!

 

 

 

2009 Advisor
posted on November 08, 2009 at 01:44PM
 
In response to AnnaBanana's post from November 08 2009 01:18PM
AnnaBanana said…

As I've said before (perhaps on the OTHER God thread), the reality of what comes next has already been in place for billions of years and does not depend on what we expect it to be.  What it boils down to is that we are free to think and believe sincerely whatever we want even though when this mortal life is over, some of us may be in for a big surprise.


(Rats, I can't turn these italics off) Some of us are in for a big surprise? I think we'll all be surprised. It just depends on how closely we've embraced the truth or have lived in denial.

The truth is unchanging no matter what we think about it!




 

 Moderator
posted on November 08, 2009 at 02:24PM
 
In response to mailforkim2's post from November 08 2009 12:25PM
mailforkim2 said…

If you like to read there is an author, Lee Strobel who wrote many books on this subject, including The Case for a Creator. He is an athiest turned Christian. He originally started out to disprove Chrstianity. He has a website. leestrobel.com. His books have now been around long enough that you can probably get used ones for a good price.


On the flip side there are a number of well know authors who "preach" that there is no God, among them Christopher Hitchens (God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything) and Richard Dawkins (The God Delusion).   

posted on November 08, 2009 at 03:07PM
 
In response to TheBard's post from November 08 2009 02:24PM

Sure enough. The original question was "...who created God?" Which implies wanting to know where we get verification for his existance and not the opposite. What I was offering was information from someone who went out to disprove the existence of God and instead found his verification. 

I very much disagree with the title  "...How Religion Poisons Everything." It is not so much religion that poisons but how men twist religion and use it for their own gain that poisons. The majority of religions (including others than Christianity) do not promote violence and hatred. Man does that and claims to do it in the name of religion.

 

 Moderator
posted on November 08, 2009 at 04:12PM
 

Religion is the creation of humans, so...

posted on November 08, 2009 at 05:43PM
 
In response to TheBard's post from November 08 2009 04:12PM

Sometimes you have to agree to disagree. We all have the right to our own beliefs.

If this is it, we live here and then just die and that's it. Then what is the point? Why live by any type of morality at all? Why not just steal when we see the opportunity, lie, cheat? We could do things like that and easily make our own lives better. If you were looking for them those kinds of opportunities would arise reguarly without much risk of being caught. Why work hard? If this is all there is and then our soul rots with our bodies why not just live to be happy instead of trying to make a good life, a good living, raise good children and be a good person? I am going to assume, because you have given me no reason to think otherwise, that you are a decent person. That if you saw a person drop their wallet and they did not know it, that you would most likely pick it up and give it back to them. Even if that person looked like they had plenty of money and would not miss whatever cash was in there. Because....why? It is the right thing to do? But if you took that money you could make your life or the lives of your children easier and happier (if you have children.)

I propose to you:

Even given the horrors that have been committed in the name of religion that without it the world would be a nightmare, a free for all, a survival of the fittest. People are not naturally good. We have to strive to be so and then learn that it is better to give than to receive. Religion is what gives us the purpose to try and be better.

Being a Christian does not mean that you are better than others. It actually can be quite difficult. You have to honestly see your own wrongs and admit to them and try to be better than you are. Being a Christian does not make me better than you at all. It simply gives me hope that I may be forgiven for wrongs that I have commited and have a better existence after this life.

Seek and you shall receive.

There are many athiest who have looked around a bit and said God and Jesus are not real. But have they really looked or just scratched the surface and then listened wholeheartedly to non beleivers? Then picked out every bad thing a christian does and said they are bad. Again I say being a Christian does not make you better than anyone else. We are all created equal and given free will. We can seek and beleive what we choose.

Which of us is right and which are wrong?

If you are right and I am wrong I have lost nothing. I likely would have lived my life the same way except for a bit less guilt. I have a feeling even non Christians live with guilt over past deeds though.

If I am right and you are wrong.... What have you lost? I do not like to think too much about that.

 

 Moderator
posted on November 08, 2009 at 09:00PM
 

Indeed what's the point?  Does belief in God make life worthwhile then it would be without God?  If so, how so?  Does belief in an afterlife really make the life we spend here on Earth meaningful?  And those who do not believe can and do leave moral lives; belief in God or following a religion does not make for a moral person; my moral compass emanates from within, not without.

My decision to put God away, to lay God to rest, so-to-speak, did not come about lightly, nor was it decision I made in a day, a week, a month, or even a year.  It took me years to finally set God aside and decided that logically he could not exist; indeed did not need to exist in order for my life to have meaning.  I do not fear death, nor for my soul.  I am at peace with my new direction and I regret it not!       

2009 Advisor
posted on November 09, 2009 at 08:25AM
 

Indeed what's the point?    It's a personal faith and belief.    You have a moral compass and belief that works for you whether you acknowledge a higher power or do not.   You as stated decided logically God could not exist--although I disagree with this.. you have decided that he does not need to exist in order for life to have meaning... and that's a personal decision you have made and have every right to make and if you are at peace, then there is no point to debate, discuss, or even understand (you've made your mind up, you've found what works for you, AND you are at peace with yourself).

Others search, have different beliefs, have different faiths and values.   It is a gift to have an increasing diversity of culture and a wide variety of people who have opinions and ideas they are willing to discuss, paritcularly when it is done to learn, to understand.

You can't be convinced to have faith... you can only be convinced to try something.  You put it on like you would a suit and see if works for you.  If it does not, you might try again, you might try something different or you might decide you don't need this suit at all.

Reasonable people should be able to share and discuss ideas and opinions as has been beautifully demonstrated on this thread.

Indeed it has been a healthy, interesting discussion.    Very well done...all.

Buttons_prev
 
1  2  3  
Buttons_next
 
Your Comment
 

General Discussions

displaying 5 of 806 discussions
displaying 1 to 5 of 806
Sticky sticky topic Locked locked topic New Posts new posts
Topic Author Views Replies Latest Post
D
Sticky Sweepstakes Winners
Meredith 1848 108
BB »
D
Sticky Let's talk about Status badges and what you want to follow you!
Meredith 1054 107
NattScatt »
D
Sticky Highest Rated Reviews Feed
Meredith 63 1
Meredith »
D
Sticky Viewpoints needs your VOTE now!
Meredith 346 33
Vetsy »
D
Sticky Locked Daily Dose of Review Ideas
Meredith 1336 59
Meredith »

Start a New Discussion