I value reviews based on experience.  Otherwise people could just browse the web, find recalls, and post them all over Viewpoints.  If your product was recalled, please share.  Otherwise you really don't know, you really don't know why it was recalled or if it was necessary to return that car seat, perhaps some of them were fine, perhaps some were replaced and now they are fine, etc etc.  The point is, you don't know, so you shouldn't share.

And how could you fairly rate this product?  Give it 1 star b/c it was recalled?  Is that fair if the product was repaired and returned to the buyers at no cost?  Is it fair if future versions of the product are fixed so they don't have the problem?