We've been with AAA only 6 mos so far but they were the lowest I could find when our policy renewed last time.  I appreciate the membership benefits and travel help and discounts.  I haven't had alot of experience and alot to share, but I don't have anything to complain about.  My particular agent is very helpful and friendly, and always willing to take care of something right away.

 I would definitely recommend that someone at least check out AAA to see how their rates compare with their current carrier.