I have two dogs, a Pitbull mix that I found in the desert and a shephard mix I got from the Humane Society and both dogs go nuts for Pup-Peroni Beef Dog Snacks. They are by far the favorite reward for our training sessions. They like other treats just fine, but when they see the Pup-Peroni bag, they know it's time to train and they quickly remember their manners to get the reward!