I am very particular and when my son had a recent soccer tournament there last month, we went there based on the overall positive reviews.  

First of all, it is NOT easy to find, so if you have a map or a GPS, that is very helpful.  I called about three times for directions and although you could tell they were very busy, they helped me each time.

Atmosphere is quaint, not really fancy and where we sat, you could actually feel the floorboard move everytime someone walked by.  

I was not particularly impressed by the waiter.  He seemed hurried and busy.  Not very overly helpful or friendly...