When I was a kid I had terrible chap lip problems in the winter. They would crack and bleed and when I tried to do something like drink orange juice it could be excruciating. I would end up using Crisco on my lips, and while it actually worked pretty well, I have to admit it makes me cringe a bit now knowing I was putting a bunch of shortening on my mouth to cure chap lips.

Thes days I use plain Chap Stick most of the time (the fruit flavors make my stomach a bit queasy) because it's easy to find and inexpensive. However, when I can find it for a good price I love Kiehl's Lip Balm #1. My wife...