On a Thursday night already packed with many good and popular shows, Supernatural rises above all of them to be the show I most look forward to. It follows the Winchester brothers, Sam and Dean, as they help people deal with a wide assortment of demonic and mythical creatures. With nothing but their black '67 Impala, a trunk full of knives, guns, and other spirit fighting hardware, and their wits they are the best in a small but well-connected underground of "hunters".

The show's writers and directors have found just the right formula of action, mystery, suspense, and humor. If you want a small...