We have had Progressive Insurance for about 7 years or so.  I have always just paid monthly since coming up with a big chunk is difficult for us.  We were up for renewal once again in February and I received the normal renewal withdrawal amount notice...everything looks the same. 

Since the beginning of the year, I have made it a challenge to myself to see how much money I can save on day to day bills so I filled out an application online for insurance quotes, changed phone services, etc.  I received a few quotes where Progressive was much lower but there were a couple that were lower than...