Wet 'n Wild IdolEyes Retractable Eye Pencil Reviews

I bought this tube of Wet n Wild Idol Eyes Eyeliner a few weeks ago when I ran out of my favorite Avon Glimmersticks and was waiting for it to arrive.  It was priced really well at only $1.99 and performed OK while I was waiting for my old standby favorite to be delivered but I would not go out of my way to buy it again. — I bought Idol Eyes because it is a retractable eyeliner rather than a pencil.  I don't like the wastefulness of pencil eyeliners so the retractable aspect appeals to me more.  Twisting the eyeliner up and down in the case… read full review »

This was the first eyeliner that I ever bought. It was really bad. It's hard to apply and smudges very quickly. I would not recommend… read full review »

I use it under the eye and it smudge withing a few hours… read full review »