2009 VIP
CyndiA
southern, NC
Don't curse the charcoal. Buy a Weber chimney starter.
5 star rating

year round griller, grill girl, prefer charcoal to gas
Pros

    simple invention, works great, no need for lighter fluid, inexpensive


SEP
22
2007

Weber Chimney Starter for Charcoal Grill — 

I can tell the difference between charcoal and gas grilled food. There's a huge flavor difference. I gas sometimes, but I mostly char grill, because that's what makes outdoor cooking different and special.

The one down side to grilling with charcoal is that some of those nuggets can be hard to start. There's the self-start charcoal and the squirt fluid, but those tastes are not what you really are shooting for. Also, you may still have a heck of a time getting the fire going.

I struggled with this problem for years. I considered an electric starter like my dad used sometimes, but we weren't always near electricity. We take our Weber on the road too.

I kept looking at the Weber charcoal starter. It sounded like a good idea. But, I wasn't sure how it worked and if it worked. It's a company I trust, but some things sound too good to be true. I wondered if this might be the case.

Finally I broke down and bought one. Since it's under $20, it wasn't a real splurge. But, still. A few dollars is a few dollars.

This thing is amazing. I kid you not.

All you do is crumple up some newspaper - 2 or 3 sheets in the bottom. Pour in charcoal. Light the paper. The coals catch up and are perfect in minutes. You then dump them in the grill, and you are a master griller with red hot coals.

Now, don't use school paper or other trash paper. That doesn't work. It does need to be thin news print paper. Trust me on this. I've tried stuffing other paper in there. Doesn't work well.

But, if you use newspaper, then you are good to go and fast with a chimney starter.

 Seriously, if you grill over charcoal, a chimney starter is a great investment. You never have to buy lighter fluid, and you save a lot of frustration too. I can't believe that I waited so long to get one. I guess I thought it sounded too simple to really be that great. I was wrong. Weber came out with a terrific low tech charcoal starter, and it only sets you back a few bucks while saving you lots over time.

 

Last edited on Sep 06, 2009



I_thumb_up Weber Chimney Starter for Charcoal Grill is recommended by CyndiA

10
helpful
votes
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
 




I_comment_shdw24 Comments about CyndiA’s Review

 


CyndiA wrote on Sep 4, 2009 at 10:03AM

In response to grillmaster's comment from Sep 4, 2009 at 9:13AM:

The chimney starter should be placed on the grill (the lower charcoal rack) and then started. When the coals are going, dump them into the grill and put the grate back on. You can see an example in the photos above.

grillmaster wrote on Sep 4, 2009 at 9:13AM

I did not like this product, I did not know that you were not to set this on concrete and it left a scorch mark on it. Also way to many sparks flew as I emptied this into the grill. For that reason alone, I will not use product again. Better to just keep the charcoal in the grill and not have sparks fly. This chimney did not get the coals going any quicker than when I used the grill.

Rainmaker wrote on Sep 26, 2007 at 4:20AM

I've used a started in this style for years. Eventually the heat causes them to rust out and I buy a replacement. My most recent is a weber and I am happy with the quality for the price. I think this one will last a while.

kevin wrote on Sep 24, 2007 at 2:00PM

I only use a charcoal starter (like this, but not by Weber) and love the results. One other tip, is that I put a few match light coals in before the normal charcoal. This ensures that the coals get lit the first time and I'm not running around stuffing more paper in the bottom.

Buggheart wrote on Sep 24, 2007 at 9:10AM

We charcoal grilled a lot this summer and I kept telling my DH about this thing. Thanks so much for the review; now I can just forward it to him so he'll know I didn't jusst invent it in my head :)

BamBam wrote on Sep 24, 2007 at 7:08AM

sound good

CyndiA wrote on Sep 23, 2007 at 5:28PM

My youngest son is very "handy." He could prob make one of these. We would have to buy the tin snips though (-:

bkovacs wrote on Sep 22, 2007 at 9:48PM

I actually made one of these a bunch of years ago with an old piece of stovepipe and some tin snips. Worked great too, and it would cost only about $5 at a Home Depot... $15 if you have to buy the tin snips!

Good review, of course.

--Bob