We Are Marshall

We Are Marshall Reviews



Overall 5 star rating4.77 of 5 (by 13 users)



We Are Marshall Review Summary

"We Are Marshall!" This is the chant heard often in this film as well as by the Viewpoints reviewers. In this film of a football team that struggles to rebuild and survive after the coaches and most of the students perish in an airplane crash, the "cast opens the door to the emotional toll such a tragedy must have taken." This cast includes Matthew McConaughey and Matthew Fox. Viewpoints reviewers report that you don't even have to be a sports fan to enjoy We Are Marshall, making it very similar to another football flick, Remember the Titans.
85% of people rated We Are Marshall  as 5 stars
85% of people rated We Are Marshall  as 5 stars%
85%
8% of people rated We Are Marshall  as 4 stars
8% of people rated We Are Marshall  as 4 stars%
8%
9% of people rated We Are Marshall  as 3 stars
9% of people rated We Are Marshall  as 3 stars%
9%
No one rated We Are Marshall  as 2 stars
No one rated We Are Marshall  as 2 stars%
0%
No one rated We Are Marshall  as 1 star
No one rated We Are Marshall  as 1 star%
0%
92% 92% of people recommend We Are Marshall 8% of people don't recommend We Are Marshall 8%
 

We Are Marshall Comparison

5 star rating Most Helpful
Favorable Review
MAR
27
2008

Bottom-Line: "WE ARE (ALL) MARSHALL."    

Directed by Joseph McGinty Nichol a.k.a. McG We Are Marshal begins with Annie Cantrell (Kate Mara) the fiancée of one of the dead players, narrating as the tragedy that was the plane crash of November 14, 1970 unfolds on the screen.  The Thundering Herd football...

read full review »
 Moderator
an infrequent movie goer, a lover of quirky unique films

TheBard
Aurora, IL
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
3 star rating Most Helpful
Critical Review
APR
29
2008
I'd heard a little about the movie We Are Marshall but didn't know the whole story. Turns out that it's a true story, about a college football team (including nearly all the coaches) that was virtually wiped out in a plane crash in 1970. The school, Marshall University in Huntington, West Virginia, was... read full review »
 Moderator
looking for something different, interested in history

bkovacs
Annandale, VA
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 

We Are Marshall Ratings and Reviews

items/page: 15 | 30 | 50 displaying 1 to 11 of 13 sort by: most helpful | date | rating


4
helpful
votes
in a football family, Movie Reviewer, a storyteller, A Big Giant Sap

SEP
30
2007
We are a football family. We live and breathe it every weekend from August until January. My husband coaches and runs a youth league that's associated with his high school alma mater, my daughter cheerleads for the same league, and my son plays football for his high school freshman team and  plays percussion in the high school band which plays at the varsity home games. There are literally some weekends where we have four games on the weekend, Thursday through Sunday. Yet, oddly, we aren't footballed out. I had seen the movie, We Are Marshall, with my kids in the theatre on one of their days off... read full review »
5 star rating
2009 Advisor
LauraBelle
South Elgin, IL



2
helpful
votes
a huge sports fan

JUL
3
2009

On November 4, 1970, a chartered airplane carrying the Marshall University football team, the entire coaching staff except for one assistant coach, the university's athletic director, and many influential people from the town of Huntington, West Virginia crashed, killing everyone on board.  We Are Marshall is the story of the rebuilding of the Marshall football team following that tragedy.

After the plane crash, Marshall is left with no athletic director, no head coach, and only four varsity players (Assistant Coach Red Dawson missed the flight for a recruiting trip, and the four players were...

read full review »
5 star rating
2009 Advisor
JazzSinger
Lafayette, LA



Reviews continue below ad
2
helpful
votes
Movie Lover

JAN
1
2008

During the 1990s and 2000s, the Marshall University football program has produced a number of players who have made their way to the NFL. Among the best known former players from the Thundering Herd are Randy Moss (New England Patriots), Chad Pennington (New York Jets), and Byron Leftwich (Atlanta Falcons). In 1970, however, the University lost almost all of its team in a West Virginia plane crash that made national headlines.The only survivors were the ones who didn't travel with the team for the round trip flight. The movie We Are Marshall tells about the first year of the rebuilding process,...

read full review »
5 star rating
reviewer
PatMills
East Chicago, IN



1
helpful
vote
a movie buff, a fan of clever plots, a comedy fan, drama fan, a screamer, a cryer, a suspense fan

FEB
17
2008

We are Marshall was well written.  What an emotional film. The casting for this film was really done well.  I didn't know the circumstances surrounding this film and the beginning of the movie just grasps your soul.  I managed to get through without a tissue - what a surprise!  As the story develops, the movie takes on a variety of comedy, sadness, hope, and determination.  We are Marshall will appeal to many different people and it's a story that everyone should hear. You don't have to be a sports fan to watch this.

Matthew McConaughey was perfect for his role as, the side-talking, Coach...

read full review »
5 star rating
2008 Advisor
BubleFan1
Houston, TX



1
helpful
vote
College football fan, Movie Lover

NOV
13
2007

I have to start this off by saying I am a HUGE college football fan.  This is an excellent movie for sports fans.  The movie follows the true life tale of the tragedy bestowed on Marshall University, when a plane crash killed the football team, coaches, and prominent members of the local community.  A new team was created in only one season, led by a new head coach and dedicated university president.

 The movie is a little heavy handed at times with the soundtrack (lots of violins during the sad parts), but that is my only complaint.  I cried at least a half a dozen times and also laughed...

read full review »
5 star rating
reviewer
Susan9472
Round Lake, IL



1
helpful
vote
Lover of quirky, unique films

NOV
15
2007

I loved this movie.  It had me from the very beginning.  When the plane crash happened I felt as though it had flown directly through my heart and the pain didn't go away for the entire movie.  The actors were all fantastic and believable.  I remember when this tragedy happened and quite honestly had almost forgotten about it.  I was born and raised in WV and I could see the heart of so many people that I know portrayed in this great movie.  I don't think you have to love or even like football to enjoy this film.  I will watch it over again many times and recommend it often.  MY opinion...

read full review »
5 star rating
reviewer
bobbie57
North Richland Hills, TX



D

DEC
11
2009

I love shopping at Marshalls. They have great prices and excellent sales. I really love their selection. I am a large woman. I wear a  size eighteen in pants and 40 in waist.  Clothes this size are very expensive. Marshalls has such great styles in the latest fashions. Oh, I just  love Marshalls. Also a huge and great selection in accessories.  It really can give you a shock when you compare mall prices to Marshall prices. The comparison is really big.  It makes me wonder why malls are so darn expensive and why are they still in business?  Who wouln't want to save money? The locations...

read full review »
5 star rating
2009 Contributor
ccunningham1
Dallas, TX



D
Movie Lover, College football fan, very picky about kids films

NOV
20
2007

I have to say this is the most tear-jerky football movie since "Brian's Song." (The original, not the remake.)  You just feel for all the people in the town and wonder how they could go on after such a tragedy. But go on they did, and in the most unconventional ways. I love movies where the characters do things out of the ordinary to accomplish something.

 I think there were a couple of expletives, but for the most part, this is safe for kids who aren't too sensitive to tragedy in film. It's a great inspirational film that goes beyond being just a football movie.


4 star rating
reviewer
shoelesshs
Winter Springs, FL



D
married, into action flicks, a pet owner, character-lover, Every day computer user, very picky about kids films, into movies that tell a great story, love chick flicks

NOV
20
2007
I'm not into sports at all but I really enjoyed the story line.  It was really sad in the beginning but I got into it without much trouble. 
I love movies with Matthew ???  in it.  His role was good. 
We have small children and we're very picky about what we allow our children to watch.  I'd have no problem watching this as a family.

5 star rating
keren6
New Plymouth, ID



D
watching chick flicks, a comedy fan

APR
28
2008
Oh my gosh I loved this movie. It is awesome, I am from West Virginia so this means alot. Must see! I love Matther McConaughey so that made the movie even better. They show the real people at the end of the movie which is nice to see. Very inspirational.
5 star rating
reviewer
ash3517
Ridgeley, WV



D
a movie buff

FEB
17
2008
Its A Buyer!! Love It!!
5 star rating
KristaLynn1807
Borger, TX



Reviews of We Are Marshall


Start a New Discussion about We Are Marshall