Water for Elephants

Water for Elephants Reviews


by Sara Gruen



Overall 5 star rating4.77 of 5 (by 31 users)



Water for Elephants Review Summary

Set in the depression era of the 1930's Water for Elephants is a historical fiction novel that chronicles an old man's memories of his life as a circus worker who looked after the animals. The old man is Jacob Jankowski, a 90-something man residing in a nursing home. He tells how he dropped out of veterinary training at Cornell University after his parents are killed in a car accident. Author Sara Gruen's descriptive narrative is so vivid, as one reviewer notes,"The story is so well written that I kept forgetting that I was reading fiction." Jacob's memories recall his train ride that ended with him employed by The Benzini Brothers Most Spectacular Show on Earth and describes the inner workings of a circus. Although one reviewer complained, "it is somewhat tarnished by the foul-language and very explicit sexual descriptions", the consensus was Water for Elephants" is well written, descriptive and poignant.". Currently available in paperback.
77% of people rated Water for Elephants as 5 stars
77% of people rated Water for Elephants as 5 stars%
77%
23% of people rated Water for Elephants as 4 stars
23% of people rated Water for Elephants as 4 stars%
23%
No one rated Water for Elephants as 3 stars
No one rated Water for Elephants as 3 stars%
0%
No one rated Water for Elephants as 2 stars
No one rated Water for Elephants as 2 stars%
0%
No one rated Water for Elephants as 1 star
No one rated Water for Elephants as 1 star%
0%
97% 97% of people recommend Water for Elephants 3% of people don't recommend Water for Elephants 3%
 

Water for Elephants Ratings and Reviews

items/page: 15 | 30 | 50 displaying 1 to 15 of 31 sort by: most helpful | date | rating


5
helpful
votes
reading non-fiction, an avid reader, twenty something, a city dweller

MAR
28
2009

Water for Elephants is a really lovely story. As a historical fiction fan, I loved how the booked tied a made up love story into actual events. The characters are all really well developed. You really fall in love with some the characters and loathe some others. The story paints a seemingly realistic picture on how the old traveling circus days must have been. This book is a quick read... funny, heartwarming, heart wrenching and thoughtful. Great lessons about love, loss, life and getting old. I highly recommend it.


4 star rating
 Community Manager
Meredith
Chicago, IL



3
helpful
votes
Not easily impressed, An avid reader

JUN
30
2007

Water for Elephants by Sara Gruen is my favorite book that I've read this year. The title alone drew me in, but I had no idea what to expect. I'm so glad I chose to read this book thougha nd I highly recommend it.

Water for Elephants is set in the depression when people would do just about anything for a little cash. It is a story about a traveling train circus, how the workers and animals are treated, the friendships that are formed, the friends who are lost and the power of love.

The whole story is told by an old man in a nursing home who can't even remember how old he is. He says he is either...

read full review »
5 star rating
2009 Writer
roserighter
Milford, MI



Reviews continue below ad
2
helpful
votes
thirtysomething, chick-lit connoisseur, a fan of quick, page turning books

MAY
17
2009

I must admit that I am a book snob in some respects.  When my sister gave me a book about a child in 19th century China, I was sure that I'd hate it.  (but I wound up loving it!)  When my mother gave me a book about a Depression-era traveling circus, again, I figured that I wouldn't like it.  WRONG. WRONG.  WRONG.  Water for Elephants is one of the best books that I've read in the past year and probably even longer than that.

Water for Elephants by Sara Gruen follows Jacob Janowski back and forth from the present as a 90-something year old nursing home resident and a twenty-something year...

read full review »
5 star rating
2009 VIP
njchicaa
Beachwood, NJ



2
helpful
votes
a fiction reader

MAY
13
2008

I would throw caution to animal lovers!  However, in the end-it would be an animal lovers dream!  I could not put this book down!  THis was a fast and easy book to read!  I would recommend having a coupld hours a free time when sitting down to read this book because you aren't going to be able to put it down!


5 star rating
reviewer
hbeeler84
Irving, IL



1
helpful
vote
a fan of clever plots, a pet owner, a fan of quick, page turning books

NOV
26
2007

Water for Elephants is an educational story which absorbs the reader into the life of a traveling circus during the Depression Era. I learned more about circus life is this fictional novel than I imagine I would from a nonfiction counterpart. The story is so well written that I kept forgetting that I was reading fiction.

Though the story is based around a circus theme, the underlying content is more about long-forgotten or long-disclosed memories. Memories of youth and innocence lost, memories of love and tragedy, memories of survival and memories of long kept secrets. I will never look at a senior...

read full review »
5 star rating
2008 Writer
rulistenin
Wild, WY



1
helpful
vote
an avid reader

AUG
3
2008
After a quarter of Water For Elephants, I actually put it down. I was turned off by the mentions of sexuality in the book.  I ended up picking it back up however because it was just such a good book.  I decided I am old enough to read a book with sex in it!  Glad I picked it back up because it just got even better.  Great book!
5 star rating
lsolkey
Ardmore, OK



1
helpful
vote
an avid reader

JUL
24
2008
I picked this book up from a friend out of boredom and have recommend it so many times.  The way the writer went back and forth between the characters memories and currentlife int he retirment home was amazing.  I found myself wanting to be tranported back in time!
5 star rating
reviewer
junkandspam4me
Blaine, WA



D
a fiction reader

FEB
25
2009
Water for Elephants is one of the most interesting books I've read recently.

To be honest, I hadn't read a book in a while.  Then I gave this a shot, and I found myself wanting to read it every free minute.

The story, characters, feel, are all just so interesting...love, adventure, unique personalities, a traveling circus, an old man with an attitude.  Even just the prologue kept me wanting to find out what happens in the end.

I wish every book I've read since this book, which was a few months ago, were as interesting as this one.  I find myself putting down many books after a few chapters because...
read full review »
5 star rating
2009 Writer
lilaichee
Palatine, IL



D
a fiction reader, an avid reader

APR
24
2009

Really liked this book.  I never would have bought it if not for the recommendation, it just didn't look like anything I normally read.  The title just doesn't grab you from the first.  This book is compelling, catches your interest from the start, and is very unique.  It will be one of the books that I actually remember out of the hundreds I read.  I highly recommend reading this book to anyone - it will appeal to many different types of people.  I liked the story, and by the end of the book I understood the title.  Very well written, easy to read, great story line, and poignant.  The...

read full review »
4 star rating
reviewer
dgambrell
Vienna, GA



D
an avid reader

FEB
26
2009
An atmospheric, gritty, and compelling novel of star-crossed lovers, set in the circus world circa 1932, by the bestselling author of Riding Lessons.

When Jacob Jankowski, recently orphaned and suddenly adrift, jumps onto a passing train, he enters a world of freaks, drifters, and misfits, a second-rate circus struggling to survive during the Great Depression, making one-night stands in town after endless town. A veterinary student who almost earned his degree, Jacob is put in charge of caring for the circus menagerie. It is there that he meets Marlena, the beautiful young star of the equestrian...
read full review »
4 star rating
reviewer
aadhu
Arlington, TX



D
an avid reader

NOV
26
2008
 

Water for Elephants is well written, descriptive and poignant.  It details the life history and feelings of the main character as he comes of age, his life as a circus worker and the life he was forced to live as he aged.  The perception between past and present was enlightening and entertaining.  It puts first person light on aging, nursing homes and losing control over the way you want to live your life.  The main protagonist had much left to say and more to give to life.  While I enjoyed the book, while reading it I told people it was too dark to say I loved it.  However, I loved the...

read full review »
5 star rating
reviewer
lisaanneoc
Mohegan Lake, NY



D
an avid reader

JAN
29
2009
Water for Elephants was a great book, especially good for discussions in book clubs.  I enjoyed the characters, especially  how descriptive the author made me see them.  The fact that the main character was telling his story in the past as a memory, as well as in the present made it seem as though he was two separate characters.  The theme of the carnival was something I had not read before, and while it was interesting to learn about the lives of those in that business, I found it more interesting to realize that people really did live that way.  I had not given much thought to those who... read full review »
5 star rating
reviewer 2009 Writer
mamasa
Columbus, IN



D

JUL
21
2009

what happens when the circus meets bygone days and one man intersects in his twighlight years?

Jacob Jankowski is over ninety years old and spending his days in a nursing home where is is miserable.  We learn over the course of the book that he spent the majority of his life working for a circus.  This was not the circus that dreams are made of.  This is a second rate circus where both the staff and the animals are abused.  Jacob in his youth studied veterinary medicine so he made himself useful to the owners.

The novel is particularly enlightening on circus history and class issues of the...

read full review »
4 star rating
jujubaker
Montclair, NJ



D
read for fun, non-fiction reader, fiction reader, character-lover

NOV
25
2007
This is a great story about the life of circus workers.  It is a harsh life, but the characters are thankful to have shelter and food as it is based during the depression.  An interesting side of the circus is presented as we see the dynamics behind the scenes.  The treatment of the animals is brutal at times which is even harder to stomach once the reader gets to know some of the animals better.  The most beautiful yet ugly parts of the novel are the relationships both human to human and human to animal.  It is encouraging as the characters hang onto dreams and their love despite the dire... read full review »
4 star rating
reviewer
valuisy
Marietta, GA



D
an avid reader

MAR
27
2009
You will never guess whodunit.  "Water for Elephants," by Sara Gruen, is more than just a good story.  "Water for Elephants" is both a mystery and a romance, and it is a coming of age story set in a depression era circus.  Sara Gruen also gives us a wonderful glimpse into what circus life in the 1930’s was like, including some wonderful old photographs of period circuses and circus performers.  And to top it off, "Water for Elephants" has an ending that I never saw coming.

"Water for Elephants" should definitely be on your "must read" list.

5 star rating
reviewer
DSZ
Newark, DE



Reviews of Water for Elephants

1  2  3  
Buttons_next
 

Start a New Discussion about Water for Elephants