Frankly, USAA is not all it's pumped up to be. It touts itself as the best in the biz but fails to live up to all the "talk." I have found that my experiences with USAA range depending on who I'm talking to. But whenever there are problems with USAA, and especially if I'm talking to a supervisor/manager, I hit a brick wall. If I were in your shoes, I would have taken my complaint to the state insurance commissioner/regulator and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Insurance companies hate it when customers get regulators involved.