The Golden Compass

The Golden Compass Reviews



Overall 3.5 star rating3.57 of 5 (by 37 users)



The Golden Compass Review Summary

With all the controversy surrounding The Golden Compass, Viewpoints moviegoers see the issue several different ways. Written as part of a trilogy by Philip Pullman, the film adaptation tells the story of a "young girl on the cusp of adulthood" who receives a golden compass, allowing her to see events, past and future. While a boycott of The Golden Compass is in effect by some, some reviewers feel it should be supported, thinking the film is anti-religion or anti-Christian. Other reviewers feel it is nothing but a fun, sci-fi fantasy film, along the lines of a Harry Potter film. While many report that their children enjoyed The Golden Compass, others that have seen the film insist it isn't meant for children as it raises too many questions.
38% of people rated The Golden Compass as 5 stars
38% of people rated The Golden Compass as 5 stars%
38%
30% of people rated The Golden Compass as 4 stars
30% of people rated The Golden Compass as 4 stars%
30%
5% of people rated The Golden Compass as 3 stars
5% of people rated The Golden Compass as 3 stars%
5%
5% of people rated The Golden Compass as 2 stars
5% of people rated The Golden Compass as 2 stars%
5%
22% of people rated The Golden Compass as 1 star
22% of people rated The Golden Compass as 1 star%
22%
70% 70% of people recommend The Golden Compass 30% of people don't recommend The Golden Compass 30%
 

The Golden Compass Comparison

5 star rating Most Helpful
Favorable Review
DEC
18
2007

I was so excited by the interesting trailers for The Golden Compass , I was rather surprised by the reation of people having comments about religion. After seeing the movie I am very surprised people are concerned about the religion aspect. Seriously after seeing movies like harry potter, lord of the...

review »
into movies that tell a great story

kjdoering
Dresden, ME
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
3 star rating Most Helpful
Critical Review
JAN
13
2008

   I recently saw the movie The Golden Compass.  I took my three children and my husband with me.  Now, my husband and my kids had not read the book, and I had.  My youngest child had started the book and not stayed with it.  I loved the book.  The book was amazing.

  From my perspective, the...

review »
watching with kids, very picky about kids films

maryellenp
Manchester, NH
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 

The Golden Compass Ratings and Reviews

items/page: 15 | 30 | 50 displaying 1 to 13 of 37 sort by: most helpful | date | rating


2
helpful
votes
married, a woman, a fan of clever plots

FEB
26
2008
I went to see this with my husband after seeing the trailers. We weren't disappointed! I haven't read the books yet (though I'm intending to after seeing this film), but the plot made sense and was enjoyable. I though Nicole Kidman did an excellent portrayal. The special effects were great.

Neither of us saw any of the "anti-Christian" themes that were supposed to be so prevalent throughout the story (and we were looking for them after all the hype) so I'm a little confused about all the boycotting. If we as adults didn't see them, then I'm not too worried about my children picking them up....
review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
2008 Writer
GMRsMom
Oakland Gardens, NY



2
helpful
votes
a woman, a lover of quirky unique films, comedy fan, a music lover, Movie guru, Lover of quirky, unique films, movie buff, college student

DEC
22
2007
Before watching "The Golden Compass", I didn't know much about the story.  There was talk among myself, friends, and even journalists about the controversy surrounding the film.  It was meant to appeal to youngster like "The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe" did; but rather than being a story about Christianity, it was meant to be a story about Athiesm.  I was a little concerned, but curious.  As a Christian, I love God with all of my heart; but as a human being, I believe that everyone is entitled to their own opinions. 

When the movie began, I was impressed with the special effects and...
review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
ghostlysun
Indiana, PA



1
helpful
vote
an action fan, into movies that tell a great story, a movie reviewer

AUG
4
2008
Nicole Kidman, Sam Elliott, Dakota Blue Richards, Daniel Craig and Eva Green play in The Golden Compass.

Plot: Lyra (Richards) travels to the far north to save her friend and the other children from the bad people who kidnapped them and try to separate them from their demons.  Demons (animals) are the humans inner soul which walk and talk with their humans.  If something happens to the demon it also happens to the human and vice versa.

What I thought:  I really like the idea of the demons and how Lyra's demon changes forms.  The demons are very fascinating to watch.  I would watch it twice just...
review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
2009 Advisor
jazzybean01
Downieville, CA



1
helpful
vote
into movies that tell a great story, into action flicks, a pet owner, married, Narnia Fan, Sci-Fi fan, Father, Movie guru

DEC
11
2007
After being excited by the interesting trailers for The Golden Compass , I was rather surprised by the calls for a boycott. After doing some basic research, I decided to both read the book and see the movie for myself. I'm glad I did. I enjoyed the movie and find much to commend, however, some of the criticisms from the Christian community are accurate and anyone seeing this movie especially with youth should be prepared to discuss the points of disagreement and why. I do not believe the movie is suitable for young children. There are scenes of peril and violence they might find disturbing.
New...
review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
reviewer
revcrab
Strawberry Plains, TN



1
helpful
vote
Movie guru

DEC
4
2007

Went to the premier of this here in Tampa last night. I was really looking forward to seeing this and all excited because I had gotten free passes. Boy was I sure disappointed and so was my husband! Granted, we're two older adults  (I'm 40 & he's 53) but we both have enjoyed other "children's" story's in the past.

I went into this not knowing anything about the story as I have never read the book. Maybe that would have made a difference. The basic plot is that there is a parallel world where there are witches, gypsies, talking polar bears (I kept waiting for them to break out the Coke and start...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
1 star rating
MsSC1985
Tampa, FL



1
helpful
vote
character-lover, a fan of clever plots, chronic book buyer, a writer, a fan of quick, page turning books, personal bookworm trainer, avid reader, fiction reader

DEC
11
2007

Pullman's The Golden Compass envelops the reader in the tale of Lyra, a young girl on the cusp of adulthood.  The first in a trilogy titled His Dark Materials, The Golden Compass embarks on a long journey which follows Lyra through much of her own world.  On a mission to save a friend, the brave Lyra, whose losses are only beginning, finds true strength in the form of friendships forged for a lifetime.

A must read, this novel gets the reader emotionally involved with all characters and with their missions. Despite, what others may have said, the novels "anti-religious" statements are not as prominent...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
reviewer
coolceruleanblue
Woodside, NY



1
helpful
vote
Sci-Fi fan

DEC
14
2007
The special effects and the scenery are stunning.  The acting, for the most part is well done. 

Despite what many Christian Groups have said this is not a particularly anti-Christian movie.  It is an anti-authoritian movie.   Most of the overty anti-religious parts of the book were gone. 

The book is, however, better.  The movie suffers from not being long enough to cover the books.   For example, the book explains the relationship between Lyra and the witches better.  Where as in the movie, when the witches do show up, the viewer is left wondering were the heck they came from.


Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
reviewer
BubbaBubba
Beltsville, MD



1
helpful
vote
comedy fan

JUN
1
2008
  The Golden Compass was AMAZING with the cute animals and amazing plotline. It goes from fairy tale to action, to plain-and-simple running for your life. The movie was good for kids, besides the one part where there was quite a bit of fighting. The good thing is, there wasn't any blood as far as I could tell.
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
reviewer
alyssa10345
Dearborn, MI



D
married, Narnia Fan, Sci-Fi fan

DEC
10
2007

I enjoyed the books, and this film, like the book, pretty much serves as a staging ground for the next two. The problem this movie movie suffers from is that they have so much story to tell, they feel compelled to repeat the important points over and over again just in case you missed them. This is pretty disruptive to the story, since the opening narration tells you everything that's going on, and figuring that out is pretty much the driving force of the plot.

 That being said, the movie is a visual feast with strong characters and a constantly moving story. A great film to see over and over...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
reviewer 2009 Contributor
renfield1969
Halethorpe, MD



D
into movies that tell a great story, Lover of quirky, unique films

DEC
23
2007
The evening I went to see The Golden Compass, I was looking for a fun, entertaing film as an "escape" from everyday affairs.  The Golden Compass fulfilled that need perfectly, with the only exception being that the movie seemed to end too soon.  I guess that is one sign of a good movie--that you don't want it to end.

The story revolves around a Lyra, a 12-year-old girl who receives a golden compass that allows her to see future or past events that she must use in her efforts to discover why other children are 'going missing' and who or what is behind these disappearances.  She is led into a grand...
review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
martron3000
Albany, NY



D
mother

DEC
16
2007

Well, first off, I didn't have much interest in seeing this movie, until all the boycotting began.  I guess I don't understand all of the drama over a movie.  As a mother, I monitor ALL of the movies and television shows my child watches.  There are plenty of movies that aren't under a boycott that I would not let my child watch, for one reason or another.

For that reason, I decided to watch the movie for myself and decide how I felt about it.  If you are someone on the fence, that maybe doesn't want to contribute to the movies revenue, I suggest getting the book from your library and making...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
3 star rating
reviewer
jajochku3
Butler, PA



D
a busy person, horror film watcher, a frequent film-goer, college student, a music lover, love to travel, into movies that tell a great story, a fan of clever plots

DEC
19
2007
So, I just got back from the movie theater and I decided to write a review about the movie. As a matter of fact, I was so pleased when I first watched the trailer of The Golden Compass and couldn't wait for the movie to be released so I could watch it. And seeing Nicole Kidman in the movie made it worth the waiting. BUT, it was not as I thought it would be. I think the movie is too short for a fantasy story, and it was fast and straightforward in its plot that it didn't need much thinking to figure out what's going on.. or even get surprised about the incidents.
The characters were OK, but I think...
review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
2 star rating
reviewer
millehoney
Indiana, PA



D
into Independent Films, character-lover, DVD collector, a fan of clever plots

MAY
4
2008

I wasn't completely sure what I was getting myself into watching this movie. I had seen previews, and heard some of the controversy, but did not know what the exact story was. The first time I watched it I was blown away. I thought it might be along the lines of a Lord of the Rings or Harry Potter movie, and it does have similarities, but it stands on its own as a highly unique, completely unpredictable and thoroughly enjoyable tale. The actor who plays Lyra, the main character, is a very talented young actress. She draws you in to her roll as an independent, slightly rebellious, clever, adventurous...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
reviewer
jlynn88
Winter Park, FL



Reviews of The Golden Compass

1  2  3  
Buttons_next
 

Start a New Discussion about The Golden Compass