reviewer
jajochku3
Butler, PA
Parenting begins at home
3 star rating

mother
Pros

    Interesting characters

Cons
    Sets up the sequel

DEC
16
2007

The Golden Compass — 

Well, first off, I didn't have much interest in seeing this movie, until all the boycotting began.  I guess I don't understand all of the drama over a movie.  As a mother, I monitor ALL of the movies and television shows my child watches.  There are plenty of movies that aren't under a boycott that I would not let my child watch, for one reason or another.

For that reason, I decided to watch the movie for myself and decide how I felt about it.  If you are someone on the fence, that maybe doesn't want to contribute to the movies revenue, I suggest getting the book from your library and making a decision from there. 

I haven't read the books and I know very little about the author.  I can't really comment on his atheist views.  However I am always disappointed to see fans of Lord of the Rings bash other fantasy movies for being anti-Christian.  There are many people who will criticize movies like this and Harry Potter, who have little or no problem with movies with language, nudity, violence, and sexual content. 

I do not think this movie is appropriate for young children.  It has more violence and adult concepts that I don't think a child would even find enjoyable.  I don't think it's even appropriate for older children who don't clearly understand the concept of make-believe.

 I enjoyed the movie more than I thought I would. It was a fantasy story about a young girl in a fictional world.  If anything bothered me, it was the naming of the spirit-animal beings (which by the way struck me as being a 'conscious' rather than a 'soul'.) 

 So basically, this is not the worst movie ever to hit the big screen, but it's a parents job to determine whether it is something their child can watch. 



I_thumb_down The Golden Compass is not recommended by jajochku3

D
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
 




I_comment_shdw24 Comments about jajochku3’s Review

 


maryellenp wrote on Jan 13, 2008 at 4:44AM

This movie is rated pg-13. It is not meant for young children.