I was SO disappointed with this eyeliner. I was looking for a long-lasting eyeliner and this did fill the bill... for about 3 months. Then, the gel eyeliner in the jar started drying out. I'd put on and the formula was so dried out it left clumps on my cheek and into my contacts. AWFUL! I contacted Smashbox and they told me they couldn't guarantee the eyeliner wouldn't dry out - I just had to make sure I closed the jar tightly after use (which I did). They told me to send to them and they'd exchange for a new jar. The new jar lasted 5 months before the same problem of drying/clumping happened. For the price, definitely not worth it - in 5 months, barely used up a quarter of the product before it was unusable! Try Bobby Brown's gel eyeliner - FAR SUPERIOR!