Smashbox Cream Eye Liner

Smashbox Cream Eye Liner Reviews



Overall 4 star rating3.83 of 5 (by 12 users)



add to my favorites email to a friend subscribe to feed

Smashbox Cream Eye Liner Review Summary

Reviewers willing to pay for quality say that Smashbox Cream Eye Liner is well worth the rather steep price. Not a powder, not really a cream, this gel eye liner is easy to apply, lasts, and doesn't run, say our beauty divas. The little pot of liner doesn't come with a brush so be sure to pick up a good eye liner brush to apply the product. Like Smashbox products? Take a look at all our Smashbox Cosmetics reviews
42% of people rated Smashbox Cream Eye Liner as 5 stars
42% of people rated Smashbox Cream Eye Liner as 5 stars%
42%
25% of people rated Smashbox Cream Eye Liner as 4 stars
25% of people rated Smashbox Cream Eye Liner as 4 stars%
25%
17% of people rated Smashbox Cream Eye Liner as 3 stars
17% of people rated Smashbox Cream Eye Liner as 3 stars%
17%
8% of people rated Smashbox Cream Eye Liner as 2 stars
8% of people rated Smashbox Cream Eye Liner as 2 stars%
8%
8% of people rated Smashbox Cream Eye Liner as 1 star
8% of people rated Smashbox Cream Eye Liner as 1 star%
8%
75% 75% of people recommend Smashbox Cream Eye Liner 25% of people don't recommend Smashbox Cream Eye Liner 25%
 

Smashbox Cream Eye Liner Comparison

5 star rating Most Helpful
Favorable Review
Slightly expensive but worth it!
AUG
28
2007

Smashbox's cream liner is super easy to apply with their brushes and it stays on a really long time. I have NEVER been able to draw a straight line with a pencil liner, so I didn't wear eyeliner...until I was introduced to this product. I would definitely recommend this cream liner to anyone who needs...

 read full review »
very happy with this product, take care of my skin

bjeanmc
Cypress, TX
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
3 star rating Most Helpful
Critical Review
I don't share my pot. Of EYELINER, that is!
JUN
29
2007

Quick View: Good eyeliner but overpriced.

About Smashbox Cream Eye Liner

This eyeliner is a tiny pot of black creamy liner to be applied with an eyeliner brush. I bought a set of Smashbox cosmetics during one of my wild "QVC Today's Special Value" excursions. I had only used a few Smashbox products...

 read full review »
2009 VIP
a beauty diva, a cosmetics junkie

PattyTherre
The heart of , NY
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 

Smashbox Cream Eye Liner Ratings and Reviews

items/page: 15 | 30 | 50 displaying 1 to 10 of 12 sort by: most helpful | date | rating


2
helpful
votes
Unbelievable product - I own six different colors!
a busy person, into trying new things, an online shopper, take care of my skin

MAR
30
2008
This product is awesome.  I have used it for years now and you couldn't convince me to use anything else!  It takes a little practice when you first try it to get just the look you want, but once learned it is the easiest eyeliner you will ever use.  This eyeliner will last all day and you can use it under the eye for a dramatic look without worrying about it ending up on your cheekbones! You are able to get the same "look" every time.  The key to this product is the Smashbox eyeliner brush.  Practice on the back of your hand to get the hang of making your "line" as thick or thin as you... read full review »
5 star rating
reviewer 2008 Contributor
justbecause
Youngtown, AZ



1
helpful
vote
thanks youtube for introducing me to this great product.
a beauty diva

MAR
21
2008
so one day i was watching an online tutorial on youtube (i love watching ppl do makeup lol) an this girl kept mentioning the smashbox cream eyeliner, well to be fair also the stila smudge pot, so anyways i decided to buy both, and i have to say that they're both great. but since this is a smashbox review, lets do that!lol i love the color, its a TRUE black, very rich and dark, its long lasting and super smudgefree. its a little pricey but very well worth it. i truly recommend it.
4 star rating
reviewer
anani
El Paso, TX



1
helpful
vote
An eyeliner that does double duty
always trying to look my best, willing to pay for quality, a beauty diva, a cosmetics junkie, into trying new things, very happy with this product, looking for good eyeshadow

SEP
18
2007
I love the verastility of this product! It even works well as a cream shadow. Just use your finger tips to smudge some on your lids for a smokey effect that lasts all night! As an eyeliner, I love that because it blends so well I dont get such a harsh line. Its a little pricier then the drugstore brands, but its worth it. And since a little bit goes a long way, you definitely get your moneys worth.
4 star rating
reviewer
wndrkat
Brea, CA



D
Im not crazy about this stuff
into trying new things, a cosmetics junkie, willing to pay for quality, a person who enjoys quality, always trying to look my best

DEC
29
2007

I did not like this to much and have stopped using it .

Maybe I was doing something wrong but it seemed to not last very long and was difficult to apply .I also saw that it created a dark line when my eyes were opened after applying about 1/2 way up to my eyebrow. I also got mine only about 20 days ago and its already drying out . By evening I saw no eyeliner on my eyes . I could not get it to make a nice even line like my pencils do no mater what I did .

Maybe it takes practice but my liner pencils do better and I can do the inside of my lower lid better with them and it lasts forever . not to mention...

 read full review »
2 star rating
2009 Writer
lorialcorn2006
Palm Coast, FL



D
Rich, beautiful colors but poor lasting ability.
wearing makeup daily, disappointed in this product, always trying new beauty products, looking for THE perfect mascara, take care of my skin, the first to try new beauty products, a mascara lover, Every day computer user

DEC
24
2007
This is just an ok product.  The colors are nice but Smashbox has a very limited offering of colors.  Application is easy.  I use the Smashbox flat liner brush and I also use the Bobbi Brown fine liner brush.  Both give great results.  The only real con with the cream liners is that they do not last.  By the middle of the day, I can see that the liner has greatly faded and smudged.  Well before the end of the day, the liner is either gone and or smudged into an awful mess.  I usually love most Smashbox products, but this one gets no love from me.  I will not buy this product again.
3 star rating
iliketoreviewstuff
Chandler, AZ



D
The best on the market!
into trying new things, willing to pay for quality, a cosmetics junkie, a person who enjoys quality, always trying to look my best

NOV
14
2007
My mom let me try this product and I was hooked. Every Smashbox show on QVC is dangerous for me. This eyeliner looks so good and is very easy to apply. When I started wearing it my coworkers noticed a difference in my makeup. I told them about the eye liner and everyone wanted to try it. Now my friends are wearing this liner, too. It is expensive, but it is quality and it lasts forever.
5 star rating
reviewer
donzigirl
Fallston, MD



D
Even I can apply it!
a cosmetics junkie, Beauty junkie

JAN
17
2008
My hands/arms are no longer limber and dexterous. I had to give up eyeliner for fear of looking like a clown or poking out my eye. The SMASHBOX brush made all the difference... I can wear liner again! It is expensive, but it lasts a long, long time. I like the tiny 10 color compact... you get variety without an overload.
4 star rating
Buffett
Prescott, MI



D
me...addicted to eyeliner.
looking for THE perfect mascara, always trying to look my best, Every day computer user, take care of my skin, looking for good eyeshadow, into trying new things, willing to pay for quality, a beauty diva

NOV
20
2007
So, i use this product to draw on my eyebrows as well as for my eyeliner.  i used the tube style liner for years until i discovered this little beauty.  nothing says precision better than using a brush and pot.  i love it and would tell every woman who loves the eyeliner to buy it.  that is all.
5 star rating
reviewer
thegirlwithahotrod
San Diego, CA



D
Good Eyeliner but dried up fast
always trying new beauty products, looking for good eyeshadow, a mascara lover, take care of my skin, a person with inherited dark circles, into natural looking cosmetics, a lip products lover, the first to try new beauty products

NOV
13
2007
I liked the eyeliner when I first bought it (went on smooth and easy) but then it dried up after about a month and I could not get it out of the little round tube. It was not any good after that. I would not recommend this product due to the fact it dried up after a month.
1 star rating
reviewer
madmax8fan
Marietta, GA



D
im so going to get me some
into trying new things, Every day computer user, always trying new beauty products

NOV
13
2007
like ive never really heard of it or seen it but it looks like something that would work.. and im so totally that person that trys new things... so pretty soon i'll have me a pair of it and it'll be in my make up bag. i really havent tried it, but to what it looks like, it looks like it will work... like usually when you think of eyeliner its like usually on a stick or the kind of new way liquid eyeliner.. but this is acually as if it was eyeshadow and you pick out like the amount that you would apply.. like i know of the eyeliner on the wooden stick, that really isn't all the good, like i heard... read full review »
5 star rating
reviewer
lldvl853
Hialeah, FL



Reviews of Smashbox Cream Eye Liner


Start a New Discussion about Smashbox Cream Eye Liner



view more in Makeup view more in Beauty