3.8
16 reviews
Other Eyeliners:
  • Average: 4.3
  • High: 5.0
Brand:
Smashbox
Smashbox Cream Eye Liner

Read 16 Reviews

REVIEW SNAPSHOT®

by PowerReviews
Smashbox Cream Eye Liner
 
3.8

(based on 16 reviews)

Ratings Distribution

  • 5 Stars

     

    (6)

  • 4 Stars

     

    (5)

  • 3 Stars

     

    (2)

  • 2 Stars

     

    (1)

  • 1 Stars

     

    (2)

75%

of respondents would recommend this to a friend.

Most Liked Positive Review

 

Slightly expensive but worth it!

Smashbox's cream liner is super easy to apply with their brushes and it stays on a really long time. I have NEVER been able to draw a straight line with a pencil liner, so...Read complete review

Smashbox's cream liner is super easy to apply with their brushes and it stays on a really long time. I have NEVER been able to draw a straight line with a pencil liner, so I didn't wear eyeliner...until I was introduced to this product. I would definitely recommend this cream liner to anyone who needs an easier alternative to applying and wearing eye liner!

VS

Most Liked Negative Review

 

Smashbox Cream Eye Liner

I bought this Smashbox Cream Eye Liner when it was at a low price than normal with codes.  I was looking for something that would not smear like liquid eyeliner and harsh putting...Read complete review

I bought this Smashbox Cream Eye Liner when it was at a low price than normal with codes.  I was looking for something that would not smear like liquid eyeliner and harsh putting on like a pencil.  I have a watery water line if you can understand what that mean.  When I draw my 'line' it tends to get watery for me and makes it hard to get that define look. That along with trying to keep passing over it with a pencil makes it rough on the water line and hurts after awhile.  When I used a liquid liner it would be find on the top but the bottom water line was another story.  Using this with an eyeliner brush, it was easy to take what I need and pass over the water line without too many passes just to get the define line I wanted.  It's much smoother drawing the line like the liquid liner.  I like the container it comes in because I can take as much or little as I want of the cream eye liner.  The price it normally goes for is not so good but it's something I would recommend to others.****

Reviewed by 16 customers

Sort by

Displaying reviews 1-10

Back to top

Previous | Next »

 
5.0

I would buy this over and over again

By 

from San Jose, CA

About Me Trendy Style

Pros

  • Doesn't Run
  • Easy Removal
  • Easy To Apply

Cons

    Best Uses

    • Smoky Look

    Comments about Smashbox Cream Eye Liner:

    try this one,the pencil helps a lot, def one of the best

    • Affiliation:
    • I received a sample

    Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

     
    4.0

    Smashbox Cream Liner is a Must Have

    By 

    from Broken Arrow, OK

    Comments about Smashbox Cream Eye Liner:

    Smashbox Cream Eye Liner is a great liner bevcause it's so versitile. You can achieve so many different looks just by simply changing the brush you use. It goes on smoothly and will not wonder to another place it should not be like your tear duct. You may look at the little pot it comes in and think it's not worth the money because you think you will go through it too quickly, but it will last you forever. It feels light and airy not gooey or greasy like some other less quality brands. One of the things I really like about this cream liner is that it lasts all day. I don't like to wear any make up while I am working out, but you know how it is, you do what you have to do, but this liner stayed in place even after a long run!
    I like water proof products but hate when I feel like I need an industrial solvent to remove them. Smashbox Cream Liner washes off completely and easily with just your basic cleanser that you normally wash your face with.
    The black and brown are definitly must haves for anybody, and not just the make up fanatics like myself, but even for somebody who just wants the basics. It is truly magical how a thin line close to the top eyelashes that is barely noticable can make you eyes look more open and your lashes look thicker.
    The only reason why I rated this cream liner a four instead of a five is because it dosen't come in enough colors. What's with that?

    Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

     
    1.0

    Worst I tried

    By 

    from Madison, AL

    Comments about Smashbox Cream Eye Liner:

    I bought a Smashbox set not long ago and it had many eyes shadows and the gel liners didn't even go on my expensive brushes. In otherwords, they were horrible! I like smashbox otherwise. They have wonderful products so I will not hold this against the company.

    Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

     
    4.0

    Good eyeliner.

    By 

    from Kingsland, GA

    Comments about Smashbox Cream Eye Liner:

    I have this eyeliner in a great shade of purple. It is a good product. It does not run, and it does not cause any irritation for my sensitive eyes. I do not really love the brush that came with it, so I use a brush that I had for another product. I would buy it again in other colors.

    Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

     
    3.0

    Rich, beautiful colors but poor lasting ability.

    By 

    from Chandler, AZ

    Comments about Smashbox Cream Eye Liner:

    This is just an ok product.  The colors are nice but Smashbox has a very limited offering of colors.  Application is easy.  I use the Smashbox flat liner brush and I also use the Bobbi Brown fine liner brush.  Both give great results.  The only real con with the cream liners is that they do not last.  By the middle of the day, I can see that the liner has greatly faded and smudged.  Well before the end of the day, the liner is either gone and or smudged into an awful mess.  I usually love most Smashbox products, but this one gets no love from me.  I will not buy this product again.

    Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

    (1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

     
    5.0

    me...addicted to eyeliner.

    By 

    from San Diego, CA

    Comments about Smashbox Cream Eye Liner:

    So, i use this product to draw on my eyebrows as well as for my eyeliner.  i used the tube style liner for years until i discovered this little beauty.  nothing says precision better than using a brush and pot.  i love it and would tell every woman who loves the eyeliner to buy it.  that is all.

    Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

    (0 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

     
    5.0

    im so going to get me some

    By 

    from Hialeah, FL

    Comments about Smashbox Cream Eye Liner:

    like ive never really heard of it or seen it but it looks like something that would work.. and im so totally that person that trys new things... so pretty soon i'll have me a pair of it and it'll be in my make up bag. i really havent tried it, but to what it looks like, it looks like it will work... like usually when you think of eyeliner its like usually on a stick or the kind of new way liquid eyeliner.. but this is acually as if it was eyeshadow and you pick out like the amount that you would apply.. like i know of the eyeliner on the wooden stick, that really isn't all the good, like i heard it can infect your eye or something like that. then there's the liquid eyeliner, i tried it once and really never knew how to do it like the experts and perfect type so i never really liked it... then there's the eyeliner that i have know that u can push up with the little sponge in the back to make the smoodge look, that eyeliner has been good... but im all ups for trying this new liner...

    Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

     
    1.0

    Good Eyeliner but dried up fast

    By 

    from Marietta, GA

    Comments about Smashbox Cream Eye Liner:

    I liked the eyeliner when I first bought it (went on smooth and easy) but then it dried up after about a month and I could not get it out of the little round tube. It was not any good after that. I would not recommend this product due to the fact it dried up after a month.

    Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

    (1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

     
    4.0

    An eyeliner that does double duty

    By 

    from Brea, CA

    Comments about Smashbox Cream Eye Liner:

    I love the verastility of this product! It even works well as a cream shadow. Just use your finger tips to smudge some on your lids for a smokey effect that lasts all night! As an eyeliner, I love that because it blends so well I dont get such a harsh line. Its a little pricier then the drugstore brands, but its worth it. And since a little bit goes a long way, you definitely get your moneys worth.

    Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

    (1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

     
    5.0

    Smashbox Cream Eye Liner

    By 

    from Neenah, WI

    Comments about Smashbox Cream Eye Liner:

    Smashbox Cream Eye Liner is creamy and dreamy!  I love all Smashbox products but they really do a wonderful job on the eye and the foundation make up.  Smashbox Cream Eye Liner comes in a nice assortment and variety of colors and is so easy to apply.  You do have to have a special brush to apply it, but it is not that expensive really and it will last you a lifetime so really it is a good value to go along with the cream eye liner.  Smashbox Cream Eye Liner applies so easily and almost effortlessly as well.  It is not waterproof though and that might be a problem for some women.  I always use a primer with my eye make up so that it does not smudge or move all day, using a good primer like the one Smashbox sells will really help to make this eye liner last all day long for you.  The colors are wonderful and there is guaranteed to be a shade that will accent and add to your eye color and compliment you! 

    Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

    Displaying reviews 1-10

    Back to top

    Previous | Next »