2009 VIP
LisaCarey
Houston, TX

Dry, Clumpy Mascara that Makes My Eye's Red and Itchy

1 star rating

busy mom, lipgloss only, budget conscious, a woman, too busy to make beds
Pros

    Brush is "okay

Cons
    Difficult to remove, mascara clump at end of brush-yuck!, Clumpy, Drying

SEP
13
2009

I got a great deal last week, with the sale at Walgreen's and my coupon my Rimmel London Eye Magnifier Eye Opening Mascara was only .49.  I hadn't use Rimmel before, but a friend of mine was all excited about getting it with her coupon, so I thought< "Hey why not, I need mascara anyway." 

I was so disappointed with Rimmel London Eye Magnifier Eye Opening Mascara.  The first application was ok, but I couldn't get it to come off! Not by washing my face, not by using a combination make up remover and facial cleaner, not even using Vaseline.  I ended up having to pull it off my eyelashes so I could start fresh. 

After a couple of days of use of Rimmel London Eye Magnifier Eye Opening Mascara I not only was not getting the amazingly long look results I had hoped for, but my eye lids at the point closest to my eyelashes were red and irritated. They itched.  So not only am I stuck with this on my eyelashes but now it's itchy and irritated too. 

A few "notes" on Rimmel London Eye Magnifier Eye Opening Mascara;

  • at first I thought the comb like brush that has some "give" would make application easier and it does,  I think it's the mascara that is difficult to apply 
  • I can't put a second coat on, one coat is not enough, I was no blessed with long lashes that just need a little help so a second coat is needed. The first coat dries and clumps quickly leaving me no way to apply a second. 
  • the irritated eye thing comes and goes, but I have already purchased a different Rimmel (look forward to that review) with a different coupon. Hopefully I will have better results with the other brand of Rimmel Mascara. 
  • My eyelashes are hard! It dries like cement and not only can I not get it off, but no one is going to want me to be fluttering these babies anywhere near them! 
Overall, it's just not right for me.  Apparently there is an ingredient that irritates my eyes and I like a softer more manageable mascara and look.  Now I know that Rimmel London Eye Magnifier Eye Opening Mascara is not for me, and off I go to see the make up wizard to find one that does work (but doesn't cost as much as my beloved Lancome). 



I_thumb_down Rimmel London Eye Magnifier Eye Opening Mascara is not recommended by LisaCarey

5
helpful
votes
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 




I_comment_shdw24 Comments about LisaCarey’s Review

 


LadyMagic wrote on Sep 19, 2009 at 8:48PM

Thanks for the warning. I won't be buying this one.

AKMEDIA2 wrote on Sep 18, 2009 at 3:03PM

Thanks for this review. Now I know not to touch this product.

PattyTherre wrote on Sep 17, 2009 at 1:21AM

So far, no Rimmel Mascara has done it for me. They have some decent cosmetics but their mascara seems off to me.

LoveisJoy wrote on Sep 16, 2009 at 6:20PM

Sounds dreadful!

AngelaWLaFon wrote on Sep 14, 2009 at 2:48PM

Oh bummer!