2009 VIP
Katrena
Piedmont, NC

The Cotton Even Falls off the Q Tips Brand Cotton Swabs

2 star rating

not happy with this product, a savvy saver, all about practical
Pros

    100% cotton, sturdy stick

Cons
    expensive, cotton comes off the stick

JUN
30
2009

I tend to purchase store brands of personal care supplies. Consistently saving money with the little things can add up over time. However, my husband was doing the shopping for me. I forgot to write down the store brand (Assured) of cotton swabs that actually did not fall off the sticks. We had been particularly disappointed with several store brands in which the cotton would come off the sticks when used. Therefore, my husband decided to get the name brand Q Tips so that he would not end up purchasing the poorly made ones.

What I like about Q Tips

  • sturdy sticks
  • 100% cotton

What I don't like about Q Tips

  • cotton comes off stick
  • more expensive than other brands
  • not a choice of colors (My kids particularly like different colored ones)

My Viewpoint:

One would think that the name brand, which costs more, would be of better quality. Nope. Not even close. The sticks are sturdier than most of the store brand cotton swabs, but if you plan to actually clean something with a Q Tip brand cotton swab, you might as well just expect the cotton to come off. Ours did.

I am disappointed with the Q Tip brand cotton swabs. Although the sticks were sturdier than most of the store brand cotton swabs that we have tried, the cotton tends to come off with use. This can pose a safety hazard. If the company is going to charge more for a product, it ought to at least be of decent quality in my book.



I_thumb_down Q Tips Cotton Swabs 500 Ea is not recommended by Katrena

3
helpful
votes
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 




I_comment_shdw24 Comments about Katrena’s Review

 


Katrena wrote on Jul 5, 2009 at 9:33PM

In response to GigiandAdonai's comment from Jul 4, 2009 at 3:58PM:

I tried the Equate first and was very disappointed because they fell off the sticks. Other reviews said the same thing. I think they use different manufacturers, so either we got a bad batch or the manufacturer that supplies our area doesn't have the quality control of the ones you buy. It's good to know that some of the Equate ones were good--I may try them again some time.

GigiandAdonai wrote on Jul 4, 2009 at 3:58PM

I Equate (Walmart's brand) 300 in a pack for about $1.29-1.49 and the cotton never comes off the stick.