I generally love Philosophy products. They're the equivalent of facial gold mines. Unfortunately, this one really falls short. First of all, they're not like other facial cloth packages. Usually the cloths are already pre-moistened to be used in place of facial cleanser. That is not the case with these. They are meant to be used in addition to your Philosophy facial cleansers. Second of all, they're designed strange. They're not just cloths, they have finger holes. That just seems ill advised to me since everyone has different sized hands. Mine are really small and the the holes are not the best fit. Lastly, they just seem unnecessary. If you want a cloth to rub your face wash on your face with, a wash cloth from your linen closet would would just as well. Maybe even better. Sorry Philosophy, this one was a swing and a miss. Effectiveness Just not effective enough to be worth buying in my opinion.