Neutrogena Skin id

Neutrogena Skin id Reviews



Overall 3.5 star rating3.69 of 5 (by 16 users)



44% of people rated Neutrogena Skin id as 5 stars
44% of people rated Neutrogena Skin id as 5 stars%
44%
19% of people rated Neutrogena Skin id as 4 stars
19% of people rated Neutrogena Skin id as 4 stars%
19%
15% of people rated Neutrogena Skin id as 3 stars
15% of people rated Neutrogena Skin id as 3 stars%
15%
13% of people rated Neutrogena Skin id as 2 stars
13% of people rated Neutrogena Skin id as 2 stars%
13%
13% of people rated Neutrogena Skin id as 1 star
13% of people rated Neutrogena Skin id as 1 star%
13%
63% 63% of people recommend Neutrogena Skin id 38% of people don't recommend Neutrogena Skin id 38%
 

Neutrogena Skin id Comparison

5 star rating Most Helpful
Favorable Review
MAY
3
2009

I have tried Pro-active, Noxema, too dial soap & water, to rubbing acholol on my face to dry out and get rid of the acne that i HAD, on my face. At the new age of 42, which i  love. i eat healthy, i exercise, daily, and care for my face as well, as the rest of Me.

Neutrogena Skin id, which i saw the...

review »
diva-in-training, keeping my skin clear

Nicolelewis0742
Wilmington, NC
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
1 star rating Most Helpful
Critical Review
MAR
18
2009
I live in a high desert so my biggest problem is DRYNESS. Even when I filled in my profile to indicate super-dry, super-sensitive skin in a desert environment they still recommended products with salicylic acid! (Even the moisturizer they gave me had s.a. -- guaranteed NOT to moisturize . . . . ) ... review »
reviewer
a dry skin sufferer

gentile
Ogden, UT
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 

Neutrogena Skin id Ratings and Reviews

items/page: 15 | 30 | 50 displaying 1 to 13 of 16 sort by: most helpful | date | rating


3
helpful
votes
keeping my skin clear, troubled by acne, au 'naturale'

APR
16
2009

Neutrogena Skin ID is by far, the best acne treatment I have ever used.  I have struggled with acne since I was a teen, and as an adult I have not been able to find a better acne treatment system.  The personalized treatment ensures that you get the right products for your skin type and lifestyle.  After taking the simple survey to get your personalized products, you get a two month supply of your products.  Although the price seems high at first, it's actually a great value because it lasts for a long time and it works so well that you don't have to use it as frequently as other products. ...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
reviewer 2009 Reviewer
mamontenegro
West Richland, WA



2
helpful
votes
keeping my skin clear, troubled by acne

APR
16
2009

When I first saw the advertisement for Neutrogena SkinID, I thought, 'o another acne product like pro-active', but then I ran out of my face cleanser which I was using for the past year, which my aesthetician recomended, which wasn't doing it's job like I was expecting it to do, and she promised it's the best thing out there. The name of it is Babor, it's made in Germany, and it just wasn't working for me. The cost of my usual cleanser was about $40, plus the day moisturizer another $40 and night cream another $40, I was already looking at over $100 just for that and it wasn't even working.  I...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
reviewer
acia979
Romeoville, IL



2
helpful
votes
troubled by acne

APR
10
2009

I have been using Neutrogena's skin ID products for a few weeks now, and have not seen a difference from using any other acne treatments.  I feel very disappointed because I had such high hopes for it, seeing as how it is supposedly personalized. It probably works for people who have success with any regular acne cleanser.  I, on the other hand, have not had true success with any product, so maybe it's just me? Anyway, this is my rating based on the results I got.  Maybe it will work better for you!


Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
3 star rating
reviewer
lorinieto
Dallas, TX



2
helpful
votes
keeping my skin clear

JAN
14
2009
THE NEUTROGENA SKIN ID KIT DEFINITELY WORKS!! THEY ASK ALL KINDS OF QUESTIONS TO KNOW YOUR LIFESTYLE AND SKIN CARE ROUTINE AND THEY FORMULATE THE BEST KIT BASED ON YOUR SKIN TYPE, STRESS LEVEL, WHERE YOU LIVE AND SO ON. MY KIT WORKS VERY WELL FOR ME. AND I ONLY HAVE TO USE IT ONCE A DAY WHICH IS A GOOD THING FOR ME BECAUSE IM NOT GOOD ON ROUTINE-THE DIRCTIONS WERE TWICE A DAY BUT MY FACE DEFINITELY WOULD DRY OUT IF I DID USE IT TWICE A DAY AND IT WORKS GREAT FOR JUST ONCE A DAY. I CURRENTLY HAVE 2 SMALL PIMPLES BUT THAT IS GREAT COMPARED TO THE FACE FULL I ALWAYS USED TO HAVE!!
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
camariluv
Jacksonville, FL



1
helpful
vote
very skin conscious, a dry skin sufferer, troubled by acne, fun loving

AUG
4
2009

Out of all the acne solutions I have ever tried, Neutrogena's skin id works the best. It is a personalized system based on your skin type and lifestyle. In order to purchase skin id, you must sign up at www.skinid.com, and take a skin evaluation so that you can be matched with the right skin-care products. The questionnaire is advertised as quick, it took me about fifteen minutes, which I don't consider quick, but it WAS worth the time. I have dry sensitive skin, which often breaks out with large red pimples (not pretty!!!!!). Most skin-care products would dry my skin out more, and leave...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
2009 Contributor
bepink1001
West Hollywood, CA



1
helpful
vote
troubled by acne

JUL
2
2009

I am Brand New to Neutrogena Skin ID and I have to say I am not sold on it. I only started to develop Acne late in High School and Just like most girls I used make –up to cover it up and over the counter acne control products. Now I am 23 years old and my Acne condition is worse than ever. I have tried most brand including Pro-active, Noxema, Clean and Clear and other Neutrogena products, pretty much everything you can find in local stores. I am Just wondering if I will ever find something. I live in Wyoming so I am in the Mountains and we have a differing kinds of climate and weather conditions....

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
2 star rating
reviewer
Jessie-WY
Lander, WY



1
helpful
vote
keeping my skin clear, troubled by acne

APR
29
2009

I've tried a lot of acne products, from over-the-counter to prescription and Skin Id is the only one I've found that is personalized specifically for my skin.  I believe that's why it's the only one where I've seen real results.  I've been using it for about 2 months and have seen great improvement in my skin's texture and tone.  Those annoying little red bumps are finally going away!


Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
reviewer
asalado
Merced, CA



D
a dry skin sufferer, troubled by acne, lipgloss only

SEP
16
2009

I've tried Neutrogena products before and had good experiences with most of them, so I thought I'd give skinID a whirl.  I filled out the online evaluation as honestly as I possibly could (making it clear that I have very sensitive skin), and I still ended up with products that caused an allergic reaction.

If you don't have sensitive skin, this product may work very well for you, but I think you can probably find products with the same ingredients at a drugstore for much cheaper.  If you have sensitive skin, you'll probably do the same thing I did, which was spend 30 minutes on the phone with...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
1 star rating
reviewer
jq2122
Austin, TX



D

APR
2
2009
I have tried just about EVERYTHING for my acne-prone skin. On SkinID's website you take a self evaluation and they find a regimen specifically designed for your skin type. I was very excited when I saw the commercial because it seems like it is very different than other products/companies because it's more personalized and not everyone's skin is the same.

It didn't end up working out for me - and I even gave it a couple months to kick in. It made my skin VERY dry and flaky. It was embarrassing. It seemed to actually make my acne worse over all. I only wish I could find something fantastic.

Oh and...
review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
2 star rating
2009 Reviewer
egaribay24
Salem, OR



D
troubled by acne

SEP
13
2009

I used the Neutrogena Skin ID recommended following the short quiz performed regarding my skin type; environment; etc.

 

I must admit that it helped my skin -- Did it clear me up -"no" but it improved my existing acne condition... Not well enuff to commit to a $40 auto-ship tho.

 

Within DAYS of discontinuing it, the acne starting coming back, just as bad - IF NOT WORSE, than it was prior to using it.

 

All I can say is try it... We are all different, so who knows?

 

 


Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
3 star rating
reviewer
CoriRenee
Harrisville, PA



D
Girly Girl

SEP
27
2009

Neutrogena skin id has helped my skin so much. I tried and tried proactiv without success so i decided to try it. Within 2 weeks it started working and my skin has never looked better. I still have occasional breakouts but it is way better! highly recommended! i also have extremely sensitive skin that broke out TERRIBLY from acnefree, clearisal, noxema etc... skin id works great with my skin. plus it is personalized so it was fun to do and is more effective!


Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
reviewer 2009 Contributor
kaylapaige
New Franken, WI



D
keeping my skin clear

AUG
12
2009

I have always had a problem with breakouts... not exteremly bad breakouts, but bad enough to make me self conscious about it. I saw the commercial for Neutrogena Skin Id and decided to give it a try since nothing else seemed to be working. I have tried various products but nothing else has helped me like the Neutorgena Skin Id. I have three products that seem to really minimize my breakouts, and on the occassion i do breakout it isn't as bad as it once was.


Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
reviewer
nycbella84
Brooklyn, NY



D
a dry skin sufferer, troubled by acne, fun loving

OCT
2
2009

the Neutrogena SkiniD system really works.  I have tried other more expensive and cheaper systems and this is the first one that actually worked within one week.  I have been usingit for one year now and have not had any breakouts.


Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
reviewer
ksleeman
Hancock, MI



Reviews of Neutrogena Skin id

1  2  
Buttons_next
 

Neutrogena Skin id Discussions

displaying 1 of 1 discussions
displaying 1 to 1 of 1
Sticky sticky topic Locked locked topic New Posts new posts
Topic Author Views Replies Latest Post
D
Neutrogena Skin id
brsall 15 0
brsall »

Start a New Discussion about Neutrogena Skin id