I really wanted to love this. I've loved every single other product I've bought by NYX, and I was hearing really great things about this mascara. I purchased it in waterproof because I do wear contacts, and having a mascara that's waterproof is a big deal for me. The marcara itself was pretty good - not great, but pretty good. It gave me decent length. It clumped a tiny bit on me, but nothing that a lash comb couldn't take care of. It didn't do much for thickness, but I'm not sure it's supposed to. But the dealbreaker for me was when I started to cry later that night. I reached up to wipe my face, and came away with black squiggles of mascara. I checked the tube to make sure the one I had was actually supposed to be waterproof - yes, it says waterproof. Yet it came off completely with my tears - I didn't even have to work at it! This was hands down the least waterproof mascara I've ever used - including ones that weren't even supposed to be waterproof! Complete and utter disappointment.