Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Foaming Cleaner Reviews

I was very disappointed in the Mr. Clean Magic Eraser.  I heard about the product from a girl at work who just raved about it.  I bought it and tried it but was very disappointed. First, it seems I needed to really wet it to get it to work.  I started to rub a mark on my tub and it wasn't coming off.  I tried to rub a little harder and made the eraser wetter, but it then fell apart.  Maybe the size should be bigger so it doesn't break up so easily.   I had another one and tried it on the sink.  Again, had to rub hard to get it to work and it didn't get rid of the soap scum and fell apart. ...

I liked the original Mr. Clean Magic Eraser, so I thought this product would be just as good.  I was sadly disappointed, though.   It did not foam like it said on the box.  I tried cleaning my bath tub with it.  (I usually use Soft Scrub to clean the bath tub).  The sponge became mutilated and did not clean the tub at all.  It does work in the kitchen, but not in the tub.  So I guess I'll stick to my original way of cleaning the tub with liquid cleanser and muscle power.

 If you use it in the kitchen or on counters or walls, I would suggest wiping again with a wet cloth in case there is...

My daughter colored on a white end table with a red crayon and nothing would take it off!  I almost gave up when I decided to try the supposed Magic Eraser.  I was stunned when it actually worked!  It came right off.

The price isn't too bad and the eraser can be used again and again.  If you are a frugal person, there are also coupons in the Sunday paper now and then.

I have never use the foaming cleaner version, but I really like the original version.  The only problem is that when it gets to the end of it's life it falls apart.  But then, I guess it is suppose to do that when you have used it for a while!  Anyhow, it does what the ads states -- removes stains like wine.

The Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Foaming Cleaner really does what the name says! I use them for everything when i am cleaning. I love them!But you really have to scrub a little hard to get the work done and they end up tearing and falling apart. However i will keep buying them. They really do work well.

These work, but I was expecting a stellar performance, based on all of the hype.  They did ok, but I have other cleaning supplies in my closet that perform equally as well.  The "sponge" concept does make it slightly more convenient.

I bought this to erase scuff marks on linoleum. It did a great job.  I tried it on bathtub ring and it worked better than any other product I've tried.