I can't say anything really negative about Mary Kay's formula 1. It isn't the absolute best mask on the market, but it ranks up there in my book. The cream part of it is a pasty white with fairly sizable blue specks in it that if you rub too hard while showering, it might be a little rough. It's pretty thick. The smell is almost non-existent (a good thing), but if you sniff it closely, it's not real pleasant. No matter as it's going to all wash off anyways. You have to have a Mary Kay dealer in order to get this, I believe, so not always the easiest to obtain. Not the cheapest mask on the market, but not the most expensive either. Basically, if you have pretty dry skin, you would probably like this. I was given this as a gift for Christmas once and even ended up ordering some more along the line somewhere. I enjoy trying different body and facial products. If I don't like something, there is always three other people in my household to use it. Scent For me, the less scent, the better. If you like a great, strong scent, you won't like this then.