4.1
10 reviews
Other Eyeliners:
  • Average: 4.3
  • High: 5.0
Brand:
Mary Kay
Mary Kay Eyeliner - All Shades

Read 10 Reviews

REVIEW SNAPSHOT®

by PowerReviews
Mary Kay Eyeliner - All Shades
 
4.1

(based on 10 reviews)

Ratings Distribution

  • 5 Stars

     

    (5)

  • 4 Stars

     

    (2)

  • 3 Stars

     

    (2)

  • 2 Stars

     

    (1)

  • 1 Stars

     

    (0)

90%

of respondents would recommend this to a friend.

Most Liked Positive Review

 

Mary Kay's liquid eyeliner is my favorite of all time

I absolutely love Mary Kay's liquid eyeliner.  I have used the pencil form, which is good too, but I just prefer the way liquid has a more defined look.  Eyeliner...Read complete review

I absolutely love Mary Kay's liquid eyeliner.  I have used the pencil form, which is good too, but I just prefer the way liquid has a more defined look.  Eyeliner is the only makeup product I cannot, or choose not to, live without.  So I've had my share of different bands.  I like Mary Kay's because it does not run, it goes on smoothly and lasts all day.  It does not claim to be waterproof but I think it is.  If I get rained on, it stays on.  If I cry a little (without rubbing my eyes!), it stays on.  If I jump in the pool (without rubbing my eyes!), its stays on.  If I do not use eye makeup remover to take it off it is a little difficult to take off.  Even after showering, there are still some remnants.  You can definitely take it off with some water, it may just take a little longer.  Some may think this is bad, but I think it is fine because that proves it stays on ALL day.  You just need eye makeup remover (I prefer Mary Kay's) to take off, if you want to take it off quickly.

VS

Most Liked Negative Review

 

mary kay eyeliner is pretty good actually!

I am very much not a fan of mary kay. So it's interesting that I actually like this product! In my opinon, they are over priced, and do not deliver the quality they...Read complete review

I am very much not a fan of mary kay. So it's interesting that I actually like this product! In my opinon, they are over priced, and do not deliver the quality they did 10 or even 5 years ago. I do not like the mechanical pencils at all! However, I love the turquoise one they had on special last spring. It smooths on perfectly! IT's very moist, but doesn't run at all. I love the color. I thought I wouldn't like the turquoise- because I have blue and green eyes. They are green in the middle around the pupel, and then they are blue In the middle, and dark blue on the outside. So I don't have blue eyes- or green eyes- or hazel eyes- they are just in between:/ SO sometimes its hard to wear blue, green or turquoise eye liners because they also change colors! Sometimes their more green, sometimes more blue, sometimes more yellowish, sometimes more aquaish. Just depend on the weather! But the consistency and smoothness of this pencil was great! The pigmentation is excellent, and is very true to the color.

I love the look this creates. It's not super bright or dramatic- it's just a nice turquoise. It's more blue than turquoise. But it's not navy. It looks very good with black mascara too. Sometimes difference colored eye liners look weird with mascara- but this one didn't. I really liked this eyeliner.

Will definitely buy againJ Great product Mary Kay! Thanks!

Reviewed by 10 customers

Displaying reviews 1-10

Back to top

 
5.0

Love this eyeliner

By 

from Provo, UT

Comments about Mary Kay Eyeliner - All Shades:

It is inexpensive as far as high rated eyeliners go, but works fabulously! I use this every day, it is easy to apply, and no need for a sharpener which also means no really sharp points to hurt your eyelids with. It comes in a variety of colors and you just can't beat the price!

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
3.0

mary kay eyeliner is pretty good actually!

By 

from Reedsville, WI

Comments about Mary Kay Eyeliner - All Shades:

I am very much not a fan of mary kay. So it's interesting that I actually like this product! In my opinon, they are over priced, and do not deliver the quality they did 10 or even 5 years ago. I do not like the mechanical pencils at all! However, I love the turquoise one they had on special last spring. It smooths on perfectly! IT's very moist, but doesn't run at all. I love the color. I thought I wouldn't like the turquoise- because I have blue and green eyes. They are green in the middle around the pupel, and then they are blue In the middle, and dark blue on the outside. So I don't have blue eyes- or green eyes- or hazel eyes- they are just in between:/ SO sometimes its hard to wear blue, green or turquoise eye liners because they also change colors! Sometimes their more green, sometimes more blue, sometimes more yellowish, sometimes more aquaish. Just depend on the weather! But the consistency and smoothness of this pencil was great! The pigmentation is excellent, and is very true to the color.

I love the look this creates. It's not super bright or dramatic- it's just a nice turquoise. It's more blue than turquoise. But it's not navy. It looks very good with black mascara too. Sometimes difference colored eye liners look weird with mascara- but this one didn't. I really liked this eyeliner.

Will definitely buy againJ Great product Mary Kay! Thanks!

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
4.0

Mary Kay Eyeliner is a one application, never smudging liner

By 

from Goreville, IL

Comments about Mary Kay Eyeliner - All Shades:

It's nice to know that when I apply my **Mary Kay Eyeliner **in the morning that it is the ONLY time that I will be applying it that day. It is long lasting, the color is just as vibrate in the evening as it is when I first apply it. It's super easy to use as there is no sharpening needed. The liner just glides right on and you are good to go. The variety of color give you more than enough looks to choose from. I have to say that I am partial to the Bronze color. I've have several compliments about the color, including from a permanent make-up artists. It can go from a natural look to a evening look very easily. It goes with multiple looks. Even though the size of the actual eye liner is small, it last forever!

  • Affiliation:
  • I received a sample

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
2.0

Mary kay eyeliner

By 

from Eureka, SD

Comments about Mary Kay Eyeliner - All Shades:

I am not such a huge fan of Mary Kay eyeliner. A Mary Kay representative came to my house and I had a few friends over and since I was hte hostess of the party, she let me use the eyeliner. I am not too big of a fan because first of all it really hurt my eyesl but I am not very good at saying no to people so I thought ahh it cant be that expensive so I guess Ill just buy it since she was harcore talking me into it. Especially since it didnt even work that well. However, when I looked in the catalog to see how much it was, I just about choked. I didnt buy it. it hurt my eyes and it was WAY too expensive! It was CRAZY expensive. I felt bad but it seriously wasnt that good. So I dont know, but honestly on me I think it looked bad, it hurt to apply, irritated my eyes, and costed a FORTUNE! So if you get a free sample or something, maybe take it and see what you think because not everyone likes the same things, and maybe you will like it, but dont spend tons!

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
3.0

easy to use

By 

from San Antonio, TX

Comments about Mary Kay Eyeliner - All Shades:

I've been using Mary Kay Eyeliner for 5 years and find it to be simple to use and it looks great. They offer several different colors - subtle earth tones for those of us who are more conservative as well as bright hues for those who like to have a little more fun. The application is easy as the product is soft and smooth and glides on well. The only downside is that I have a difficult time gauging when I am almost at the end of the product. I believe there are small guidelines at the top where you are supposed to be able to detect when you are close to the end, but so far that has alluded me so I tend to run out and then be stuck without any eyeliner until my consultant can get me more. So you might want to always have a second one on hand. The price is average, maybe a little more than drugstore eyeliners, but I feel that the trust in the quality of this product is worth the extra expense.

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
5.0

My Favorite Mary Kay product

By 

from Tremont, IL

Comments about Mary Kay Eyeliner - All Shades:

This product is by far my favorite Mary Kay product and my favorite eyeliner.  Prior to using Mary Kay products, I didnot use eyeliner regularly.  I am not real high-mantanence and all the other eyeliners I had tried were either hard to put on or smudged from wearing them (I tend to tought my eyes a lot durig the day)  However, I love this eyeliner because when you put it on, you can blend it (so it is not so dark) but it will not smudge down.  It also easily comes off with eye make-up remover.  I also love that it is a mechanical pencil and does not need to be sharpened.  Along with the qualities of the product, I also love the colors it comes in.  My two favorite are Bronze and Amethyst.  I love the Bronze because it is very subtle and it seems like it looks good on most people.  The Amethyst, I thought I would never wear, but I got new glasses that are purple and it complements the purple in my glasses and brings out the green in my eyes.

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

 
5.0

smooth

By 

from Russellville, KY

Comments about Mary Kay Eyeliner - All Shades:

I have used this mary kay eyeliner for a long time. this is great product that is worth the money. i am lucky because my sister sells mary kay so she offers me this eyeliner at her price. i stock up when i can because it is great to keep on hand. i love that this eyeliner is retractable. i don't have to spend time sharpening an eyeliner pencil. it always goes on so smooth and i can smudge it for a softer look. It doesn't run under my eyes.  it stays where it is supposed to.  it lasts all day and even all night without rubbing off. i use the brown the most.  i have blue eyes and it always looks darker than brown.  but i still love that about it.  it can look different on all kinds of eye colors.  it comes off easy with soap and water and the mary kay makeup remover.  i know it can be a little expensive but it is worth the money for this high quality product. give this a try and find a representative in your area. 

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

 
5.0

The best I've ever used

By 

from Fort Wayne, IN

Comments about Mary Kay Eyeliner - All Shades:

I have been using Mary Kay eyeliner for about seven years now.  It is the ONLY eyeliner stick/roll up that does not smear or "bleed" under my eyes, giving me raccoon eyes.  I have tried expensive upscale store brands and cheaper brands from the drug store.  I cannot go without eyeliner when putting on make-up and this brand is seriously the best I have ever used.  I use the former Sable color still as I bought them up when they discountinued the name.  It is an awesome color and never leaves me with raccoon eyes.  The Mary Kay eyeliners are easy to remove with the eye makeup remover as well.  Whenever I find someone selling Mary Kay, I buy these eyeliners in multiple quantities because I NEVER want to run out, ha!  I love the look of liquid eyeliner but cannot seem to master applying it.  With this eyeliner stick, it is a no hassle use and looks great.  It goes on smooth and creamy and has never pulled my skin.  I simply love it!

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

 
5.0

Long-wearing and Easy to Apply - Mary Kay Eyeliner

By 

from Rochester, NY

Comments about Mary Kay Eyeliner - All Shades:

As a 10 year Mary Kay cosmetics user and a former Mary Kay consultant, I can't say enough about Mary Kay eyeliner.  Both the liquid eyeliner and pencil eyeliner are professional and easy to use products.  I use almost 100% Mary Kay makeup and eyeliner is something I will always buy from Mary Kay.  The price is worth the quality!

The best thing about Mary Kay eyeliner is how long is lasts (6-8 hours) and that is is very smudge resistant.  I never have "racoon eyes" with Mary Kay eyeliner, like I do with other brands.  I also love that the eyeliner pencils are self-sharpening, so you don't need to worry about having a sharpener handy.  The pencil glides on smoothly.  You don't feel like you are pushing hard or poking yourself in the eye to get a nice, thick line.  The pencil is easy to control.

The only downside to Mary Kay eyeliner is that you have to get it from a Mary Kay consultant.  Mary Kay doesn't sell their products online without going through a consultant.  Since I stopped selling Mary Kay myself, I've had to plan ahead more to make sure I always have eyeliner.  Of course, there is also the issue that some Mary Kay consultants can be kind of annoying, constantly following up with you after you order something from them.  But other than the fact that Mary Kay products are harder to get than other cosmetic brands, I'd recommend their eyeliner to anyone.

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

(3 of 3 customers found this review helpful)

 
4.0

Mary Kay's liquid eyeliner is my favorite of all time

By 

from Newport News, VA

Comments about Mary Kay Eyeliner - All Shades:

I absolutely love Mary Kay's liquid eyeliner.  I have used the pencil form, which is good too, but I just prefer the way liquid has a more defined look.  Eyeliner is the only makeup product I cannot, or choose not to, live without.  So I've had my share of different bands.  I like Mary Kay's because it does not run, it goes on smoothly and lasts all day.  It does not claim to be waterproof but I think it is.  If I get rained on, it stays on.  If I cry a little (without rubbing my eyes!), it stays on.  If I jump in the pool (without rubbing my eyes!), its stays on.  If I do not use eye makeup remover to take it off it is a little difficult to take off.  Even after showering, there are still some remnants.  You can definitely take it off with some water, it may just take a little longer.  Some may think this is bad, but I think it is fine because that proves it stays on ALL day.  You just need eye makeup remover (I prefer Mary Kay's) to take off, if you want to take it off quickly.

Comment on this reviewHelp Icon

Displaying reviews 1-10

Back to top