2009 VIP
GigiandAdonai
Luvs2Dance, SC

Subtle shades of earth tones that aren't too dark or drab.

3 star rating

a dry skin sufferer, into trying new things, a mascara lover, fun loving, a cosmetics junkie, value conscious, Princess-in-training, cost-conscious
show all »
Pros

    color palette is beautiful, not too expensive

Cons
    can irritate sensitive eyes

NOV
5
2009

Back in 2001 I bought a complete line of L'Oreal makeup and within two days I discovered that I couldn't wear the eyeshadow.  It had some sort of fragrance in it that irritated my eyelids and the skin literally peeled off.  I knew it was the makeup because once I quit using it my eyes cleared up within days.  I returned to my old faithful Clinique and was content for years.  But then I bought a new home and decided that I needed to cut some corners and went back to my drugstore makeup versus the elite lines.  I have done well until last week.

I was in need of eyeshadow and mascara.  PattyTherre had posted an awesome review on the L'Oreal Telescopic Explosion mascara and I just knew I had to get me some.  So while out hunting for that I checked out the eyeshadow.  L'Oreal has a color line and the "For Brown Eyes" was beautiful.  I remembered the problem I had with the eyeshadow several years ago but I just wanted to believe that was a fluke and I could try it again.  So, I purchased the L'Oreal Wear Infinite Eye Shadow (Summer Dusk/508).  This eyeshadow has soft shades of brown and khaki and slight hints of plum.  You get four shades and they are beautiful.  I paid $5.97 at Walmart and by the way, I couldn't find the L'Oreal Telescopic Explosion mascara.  That will be in another review.

Saturday evening I'm getting ready for the Hallow-Him activity at my church.  When I began to apply the eyeshadow I noticed my eyes got a little tingly and started to water and my first thought was, "Oh, no!  Here we go again!"  I finished my makeup and went on to church.  I got a lot of compliments on my eyes because I had ventured out and wore all four colors so they stood out but not in a flamboyant way!  Throughout the evening I paid attention to how my eyes felt and I thought I was going to be okay.  But when I came home and started to take my makeup off I could tell that my lids were still tingling.  Even makeup remover wipes for sensitive skin were "hurting" them.  Sunday morning I wake up and my eyes are swollen something fierce.  My left eye will barely open and both lids had scaly skin on them so I knew I had once again reacted to the makeup.  It seems that L'Oreal has some sort of fragrance in the powder and people with sensitive skin or eyes can't handle it.  I have even noticed it with the Voluminous Mascara when i first start a new tube but then I just ignore it because that is on my eyelashes so not really effecting my skin.

I am only giving the product 3 stars because I know that for whatever reason I cannot use it.  I don't have a problem with L'Oreal skin care products, lipsticks, or mascaras per se.  I've never tried blush so I'm not sure if I would have a similar reaction.  After church on Sunday I went back to Walmart to get a refund on the eyeshadow and that was a blessing in disguise because after searching for a week there was the Telescopic Explosion Mascara!

The L'Oreal collection has a color line that you can coordinate all your makeup products with your eye color.  I am always reluctant to go after the brown eyes or autumn colors because I don't care for earth tones as much as I love the plums and mauves.  But I was pleasantly surprised to see that L'Oreal incorporates the plums into the brown eye collection.  I think L'Oreal also does seasonal colors because when I was trying to find the primary photo for Summer Dusk I kept coming across the "For Brown Eyes" collection that was called Just My Imagination and it had a different number and the colors were more vibrant.  So, I'm thinking they do a spring/summer shade and then a fall/winter shade.

I will still recommend the L'Oreal Wear Infinite Eye Shadow (Summer Dusk/508) because it is a beautiful color for someone who has brown eyes or who just likes those hues.  I was also very impressed with the $5.97 price tag because I thought the L'Oreal makeup would be more expensive.  If you have concerns about allergies or sensitivities to eye makeup I would recommend you purchase the product from a store that has a very good refund/exchange policy so that if you need to return it you can.  I didn't have a problem getting my money back at Walmart.  I let them know I had used the eyeshadow the night before but that due to eye sensitivity I couldn't continue to use it.  They gave me a full refund without any problem.

 



I_thumb_up L'Oreal Wear Infinite Eye Shadow-Summer Dusk (508) is recommended by GigiandAdonai

3
helpful
votes
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 




I_comment_shdw24 Comments about GigiandAdonai’s Review

 


PattyTherre wrote on Nov 10, 2009 at 10:18PM

The colors sound really pretty. I have never had a bad reaction to eye shadows that I recall but some just worked better than others for me. I don't like a lot of shimmer so my choices are fairly limited. I would actually like to try this one if it isn't too shimmery.

Jo wrote on Nov 8, 2009 at 10:09AM

Hey Gig, good to see you:)

LoveisJoy wrote on Nov 6, 2009 at 7:00PM

The colors sound lovely. It's a shame you couldn't wear it without irritation.