reviewer 2008 Contributor
woodredhead
Huntington Woods, MI

School is more than academics

1 star rating

25 years in education
Pros

    No Attendance Problems, Fieldtrips to all the best places

Cons
    mom or dad could miss a subject, Unprepared to work with others, Fear, it lonely for the kid

MAR
16
2008

There is no one best way to educate children. Every child is different, and has different needs, learns differently, views the world differently. But school isn't just about learning a particular collection of knowledge or a set of skills. Business people in the marketplace say that we can't teach kids what they need to know to do the jobs they will eventually get in the future because those jobs don't even exist yet. What they need us to teach them is how to be a team player, how to see the world as a global society, how to get along well with others, how to understand that people from other cultures see things differently than we do and not only is that ok - we need to market to that difference and so on. You can not learn those things in isolation. Even home schools that are collections of a few families are not microcosms of society. When students arrive at my high school after having spent their early years in a home school setting - they may read well, they may be very intelligent - but they don't know how to interact with their peers. They don't join student organizations, they don't get involved with any clubs or sports. They continue to isolate themselves.

If you are trying to protect your child from a dangerous world by home-schooling them - you are doing them a disservice. They will be in more danger as they will not have the social skills to be able to communicate and may actually put themselves in a dangerous situation unknowingly. There is a story I always share when people are denying themselves or others something in the name of safety or protection from harm. A student of mine had an aunt who had planned a trip to Europe. The planning had taken over a year and she had been saving for the trip for several years. The night before she was to leave she had a dream about a train she was on crashing. She got up that morning and cancelled her trip. That day she went into Boston to do some shopping. She was coming out of a store when a bus jumped the curb, struck and killed her. Moral of the story - if it is your time - it is your time. Don't homeschool for protection - it's bad reasoning.

Kids need to be with other kids. They need to take classes like robotics, web design, international foods, scuba diving - these are all classes at my school. I would hate to think my daughters would miss these opportunities to be a year or two ahead in reading.



1
helpful
vote
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 




I_comment_shdw24 Comments about woodredhead’s Review

 


alrp wrote on Jan 8, 2009 at 1:48PM

It is not just about being a team player. Do we really want our children to be a part of at least half of the teams that are found in schools? It is about being moral. Society for the most party has no morals any longer. What happens when they are not part of the "popular" team? They either end up with any group that will accept them or they end up lonely and with low self esteem. Often times they are bullied. Public school focuses too much on what society says is acceptable. Again, often times this is not what is actually moral or what we want our children to be influenced by. The not typical or liberal kids fall between the cracks.

ebowen1973 wrote on May 22, 2008 at 7:39PM

Yes, school is so much more than education. It's a place where children lose their innocence. A place where they are offered drugs, bullied, passed along year after year whether they comprehend what is being taught or not. A place where very few adult care about them. A place where kids learn that to get ahead, they have to flatter, cheat, lie,etc. Homeschool for protection and really prepare kids for what the world is. Yes, it's a cold world out there. I want my kids to be prepared for it, not like so many "A" students who don't have a clue how to get along in the real world, or so many fashionable students who don't realize they actually need a JOB and know how to BUDGET in order to wear the latest styles. Homeschooling is more than education. It's being aware of what is going on in the REAL world. How banks work, museums, interest in a wide variety of subjects. how to get along with real people in the real world. not just the academic world of schools.