Gone Baby Gone

Gone Baby Gone Reviews



Overall 4.5 star rating4.33 of 5 (by 36 users)



Gone Baby Gone Review Summary

Gone, Baby, Gone is a "powerful, unsettling movie." Ben Affleck's directorial debut tells the story of a young lost girl with an unfit mother. Starring Ben's brother, Casey, Gone, Baby, Gone, shows "everything from the point of view of local people," which has Viewpoints moviegoers leaving the theatre or turning off the DVD feeling torn, a feeling based solely on the story, which had them questioning right from wrong. Based on a movie by the Mystic River author, no one can decide what is best for this little girl from a neglectful home. Reviewers found Gone, Baby, Gone to be "Good, Baby, Good," and left them thinking of this "moral wrestling match."
56% of people rated Gone Baby Gone as 5 stars
56% of people rated Gone Baby Gone as 5 stars%
56%
33% of people rated Gone Baby Gone as 4 stars
33% of people rated Gone Baby Gone as 4 stars%
33%
4% of people rated Gone Baby Gone as 3 stars
4% of people rated Gone Baby Gone as 3 stars%
4%
6% of people rated Gone Baby Gone as 2 stars
6% of people rated Gone Baby Gone as 2 stars%
6%
3% of people rated Gone Baby Gone as 1 star
3% of people rated Gone Baby Gone as 1 star%
3%
86% 86% of people recommend Gone Baby Gone 14% of people don't recommend Gone Baby Gone 14%
 

Gone Baby Gone Comparison

5 star rating Most Helpful
Favorable Review
OCT
20
2007

This review is spoiler-free! 

The Case

We get a lot of free movie passes and advance screening tickets in the mail, and the latest one was for a movie called Gone Baby Gone.  Honestly, I'd never heard of it.  Had to look it up to find out who was in it and what it was about.  A cop movie.  Really? ...

review »
character-lover, a fan of clever plots

Nicole
Austin, TX
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
2 star rating Most Helpful
Critical Review
MAY
15
2008
I can say very few good things about this movie.   The storyline was bad.  The actors and actresses did a bad job.  It made me a little sick with the child molesters and killers.  Ed Harris and Morgan Freeman do a pretty good job as detectives in this horrific tale about this little girl who was... review »
2008 Contributor
a movie buff, watching chick flicks

domesticqueen23
Carthage, MO
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 

Gone Baby Gone Ratings and Reviews

items/page: 15 | 30 | 50 displaying 1 to 13 of 36 sort by: most helpful | date | rating


5
helpful
votes
looking for something different, into movies that tell a great story, looking to be entertained

FEB
20
2008

I didn't know much about Gone Baby Gone when I got it from Netflix, only that it was directed by Ben Affleck and that maybe Matt Damon had something to do with it. The film is actually Ben Affleck's debut as a director, and the lead character (Patrick Kenzie) is played by Casey Affleck, Ben's brother.

Gone Baby Gone is a story about a missing four-year-old girl who may or may not be kidnapped. The child's mother (played superbly by Amy Ryan) quickly turns out to be chillingly unfit and the girl could be anywhere... including dead. Patrick Kenzie and his girlfriend/partner Angie (played by Michelle...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
 Moderator
bkovacs
Annandale, VA



5
helpful
votes
into Independent Films, a comedy fan, a bargain hunter, movie lover, Christian

APR
26
2008
Within the first few minutes of watching GONE BABY GONE you know that you're about to watch a good movie.  There's never a dull moment in moviebecause  it demands your attention from start to finish.

At the very start of GONE BABY GONE a 4-year-old girl is missing.  The movie is set in a tough Boston neighborhood, and private investigators Patrick Kenzie and Angela Gennaro (Casey Affleck and Michelle Monaghan) are asked by the family of the missing girl to assist in solving the case by contacting people who will not talk to the police.  When 4 year old Amanda McCready disappears from her...
review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
2008 Writer
wellow
Chicago, IL



Reviews continue below ad
3
helpful
votes
movie buff, first in line on opening weekend, Lover of quirky, unique films, a movie guru

NOV
24
2007

Gone Baby Gone, is one of those rare films that makes you think long and hard about the decisions which the characters must face.  Ben Affleck decided to direct a story written by Dennis Lehane, the same author who wrote Mystic River.  If you have seen that film, then you know what you are getting into with this film based almost entirely in the city of Boston.  This is where the movie really shines, as it shows everything from the point-of-view of local people, and stars an original in the form of Casey Affleck.  The most important thing is to not get bogged down by the background of either...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
2009 Advisor
SpokaneMan
Spokane, WA



3
helpful
votes
first in line on opening weekend, Movie Reviewer, a cult film connoisseur

OCT
25
2007

I don't know if I've ever been so torn about how I felt coming out of a film as I have last Saturday night at the end of Gone Baby Gone.

You see, as someone who watches with a critical eye, I appreciate every reason why Gone Baby Gone is one of the best films of the year.  First time director Ben Affleck does a heck of a job.  His younger brother Casey turns in a great performance, just one of many by the film's cast.  It makes you think, it unsettles you, it challenges you on the line of what is right and what is wrong; it asks questions most films wouldn't touch, and revels in bringing to...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
MattA75
South Berwick, ME



2
helpful
votes
into movies that tell a great story, Love a story line that makes me think

NOV
18
2007

This movie is hard to review without including spoilers, so read on at your own risk.

 I really liked this movie because it made me think. I love anything that works my brain, and ethics is one of those things. The ethics that come up for grabs in this story involve people making judgments about what is best for a child in a home where she really is not getting the best of care, though there is no overt physical abuse. Mostly the problem is neglect - so at the end of the movie when **!!!SPOILER!!!** the child is found to be in the care of the retired police chief and his wife because they think...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
reviewer
IrishRush
60525



2
helpful
votes
into Independent Films, a movie buff, into action flicks

MAR
23
2008

As soon as I heard Ben Afflect was going to be directing this movie I immediately called my friend and made sure we would be there on opening day.  Sure he has had alot to do with the production of many other movies but this was going to be his first time directing on his own.  The beinning caught my eye and held my attention.  Bringing his brother Casey into the film was a brillant idea because Casey Afflect is an amazing actor...however Ben Afflect is not a good director.  The movie itself was good however the angles and the way alot of the situation were portrayed made it a difficult movie...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
2 star rating
reviewer
alygirl25
Sun Prairie, WI



1
helpful
vote
a fan of clever plots, into movies that tell a great story, Love a story line that makes me think, DVD collector

NOV
20
2007

I was very impressed with the movie.  First of all, I think Ben Afflec did a very good job as a director, specially considering that it is his first movie as a director.  Morgan Freeman is a very good actor so no surprises with his wonderful performance.  However, his part is not so big.  I was very impressed also with Cassey Afflec, Ben's brother, who did a very good job too.  I know he has done several movies before but he is not as known as other big actors and did a very true performance.

 The ending is very good.  I don't want to reveal anything but it is for sure very well thought...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
reviewer
dbengio
Los Angeles, CA



1
helpful
vote
horror fan, a fan of clever plots, into movies that tell a great story, Love a story line that makes me think, movie buff, Lover of quirky, unique films, DVD collector

DEC
18
2007
I have to admit that I did not really want to see this movie. Although I do love the actors and I was curious to see how Ben Affleck would do with the direction, it seemed like a really average story. The beginning was slow and although the story of a kidnapped child is heartbreaking, it is a movie that has been done in the past. The movie did start to pick up towards the middle and let me tell you by the end, I was enthralled. It is a very tumultuous ending that will no doubt leave you wondering, what would I have done? If you like neat, happy endings, DO NOT see this movie. There are several... review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
Jessiek
Spencer, TN



1
helpful
vote
first in line on opening weekend, Lover of quirky, unique films, into movies that tell a great story

DEC
18
2007
First of all I am from the Boston area and most of the actors who are not from Boston did an excellent job with the accent. I find it annoying when actors do the Boston accent and it's waaaaay off. There were many times in the movie where I couldn't even guess what was going to happen next. I found myself empathizing with the characters at one point and then totally changing my mind later on. Personally I didn't like the ending but I'm sure if you polled everyone who saw the movie you would get many mixed reviews. I see that some people were bothered by the language but to me it was realistic.... review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
reviewer
zuzuspetals
Saugus, MA



1
helpful
vote
a movie buff, Drama Lady, Likes to be entertained

AUG
29
2008

This movie actually made me cry, as it was about the disapperance of a child, and the twists and turns that came out little by little. At first you get this picture of a mom that looks distraught, then you get to see her for what she is. And you get this investigator who goes all the way with his job, no half-done's.

I did think it was highly disturbing, though, when you see the child molester and what he did to a boy. I almost threw up, it was so disgusting.

All in all the end was pretty suprising, I DID NOT LIKE the ending. I thought it was bad of Casey to report the situation. The little girl...

review »
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
reviewer
ajrivera
El Monte, CA



1
helpful
vote
a movie buff, into action flicks, a comedy fan

MAR
21
2008
I was hesitant about watching this movie, but it ended up being really great.  I have to admit that I watch a lot of movies and lately there just haven't been that many great ones.  I was impressed with Casey Affleck's acting and the rest of the cast was great as well.  Just when you think you have the movie figured out, they surprise you with a few twists.  The ending is definitely something that makes you wonder what you would do.  And just like Casey Affleck and his girlfriend in the movie, my husband and I had different opinions on the right thing to do. 
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
reviewer
flvixen32
Stuart, FL



1
helpful
vote
into Independent Films, a movie buff, a woman

MAR
2
2008
Casey Affleck, while he may have done movies before, steps front and center in this and does a fine job.  His brother, Ben, deserves kudos as well, directing this very intricate plot and shaping these amazing characters.  The acting is right-on with many true blue Bostonians being cast. Still, known actors such as Morgan Freeman, Ed Harris and Amy Madigan provide a stable framework for this film.  There is some disturbing material, but nothing like I prepared myself for.  It is more about situational ethics than child abduction.  Take a look.
Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
4 star rating
reviewer 2008 Contributor
QueenofScones
Lakeland, FL



1
helpful
vote
a fan of clever plots, single guy

JAN
23
2008

Put this movie on your absolute must-see list. The middle of the movie is admittedly a little cryptic, but it all makes sense once the ending is in place. "Gone Baby Gone" asks some moral questions that are surprisingly difficult to answer. Wow, what a great movie!


Did you find this review helpful?
 
 
5 star rating
 Staff
Kyle
Chicago, IL



Reviews of Gone Baby Gone

1  2  3  
Buttons_next
 

Start a New Discussion about Gone Baby Gone