Autos Baby Beauty Books Computers Education Electronics Health Home & Garden Local Places Movies Pets Travel Web Sites more…
Gone Baby Gone

Gone Baby Gone Review



Overall 4.33 of 5 view all 33 reviews



If you think right and wrong is black and white, see this movie
4 star rating

into movies that tell a great story, Love a story line that makes me think
Pros

    Will Leave You Thinking, Directing Style, Performances


NOV
18
2007

This movie is hard to review without including spoilers, so read on at your own risk.

 I really liked this movie because it made me think. I love anything that works my brain, and ethics is one of those things. The ethics that come up for grabs in this story involve people making judgments about what is best for a child in a home where she really is not getting the best of care, though there is no overt physical abuse. Mostly the problem is neglect - so at the end of the movie when **!!!SPOILER!!!** the child is found to be in the care of the retired police chief and his wife because they think they can give her a better life, and not dead like everyone in the theater thought, the dilemma the thinking audience has is who is right. Should the child be returned to her drinking, drug abusing, promiscuous and neglectful mother who loves her daughter but hasn't made her the number one priority in her life, or should the child be left with the retired police chief and his wife who will raise her in a loving, caring home and give her all she needs? The simple answer is obvious of course, but if you put yourself in the shoes of the mother, and try to do it without judging her, then also listen to the logic of the PI who finds the child, and the simple answer suddenly stops being so simple.

All I can say is if you enjoy ethics / philosophy, SEE THIS MOVIE. The acting is good, the directing is good, the story is good. The language is a little rough, but appropriate for the context. Definitely worth the price of admission.

Last edited on Feb 20, 2008


I_thumb_up Gone Baby Gone is recommended by IrishRush


2
helpful
votes
Did you find this review helpful?
Review inappropriate? Copyright violation?




I_comment_shdw24 Comments about IrishRush’s Review



Knana wrote on Dec 4, 2007 at 8:19PM


I agree with you completely. This movie has everything going for it--tremendously interesting story, great acting, & directing. I had never seen Casey Affleck before and thought he was terrific. His brother did a wonderful job at his first episode of directing. The nitty-grittiness of the low end neighborhood added to the mood of the film. The ending sure was legally the right thing to do, but, personally, I wouldn't have taken the girl back to her very low-life(superbly acted)mother. All part of the conundrum this movie presents.