Autos Baby Beauty Books Computers Education Electronics Health Home & Garden Local Places Movies Pets Travel Web Sites more…
Home » Books & Magazines » Book Reviews » Elizabeth Gilbert - Eat, Pray, Love: One Woman's Search for Everything Across Italy, India And Indonesia... » Wondermima's Review
Elizabeth Gilbert - Eat, Pray, Love: One Woman's Search for Everything Across Italy, India And Indonesia Books

Elizabeth Gilbert - Eat, Pray, Love: One Woman's Search for Everything Across Italy, India And Indonesia Books Review



Overall 4.59 of 5 view all 29 reviews


add to my favorites email to a friend view more Book Reviews

reviewer
Wondermima
Heath Springs, SC
add Wondermima to my friends list
Earnestly looking for something, anything to have meaning...
3 star rating

reading non-fiction, a fiction reader, an avid reader, re-reading the classics
Pros

    Insight - mind of the modern mystic., honest and down to earth

Cons
    Illogical

MAR
5
2008
"Eat, Love, Pray" is about one womans search through herself and three countries to find God and love herself. Although Gilbert is an easy enough to read writer with a funny and self depricating sense of humor, her illogical presuppositions in the beginning of the book about 'God' and religion ruin the journey. She says "Let me first explain why I use the word God, when I could just as easily use the word Jehovah, Allah, Shiva, Brahma, Vishnu or Zeus." This sort of illogical thinking does no service to her 'spiritual journey'. You cannot go assigning deitys of certain religions to other religions. What do these God's say about themselves according to their own scriptures? They would certainly not agree to all be lumped together into one called 'God'. This ruins the 'journey' for the reader, partly because it shows her lack of knowledge of these 'Gods', but also because it seems as if she has already arrived at her conlusions. She has already boxed 'God' into some sort of albeit vague, hazy and continually morphing, box! This seems to me the exact opposite of what she said she wanted to do. It is possible to be so inclusive that you lose respect for the separateness of the religions that she so completely assualted by lumping their deitys into one SuperPower.

I_thumb_down Elizabeth Gilbert - Eat, Pray, Love: One Woman's Search... is not recommended by Wondermima


D
Did you find this review helpful?
Review inappropriate?




I_comment_shdw24 Comments about Wondermima’s Review



5 star rating
"Great tale of change and growth"
More Elizabeth Gilbert - Eat, Pray, Love: One Woman's Search for Everything Across Italy, India And Indonesia Books reviews
3 star rating
"What's the hoopla about?"


Other reviews by Wondermima
add Wondermima to my friends list

4 star ratingLindt & Sprungli Lindt Excellence 70% Cocoa Review - "Solid, but not the...
5 star ratingLindt Lindor Truffles Review - "Smooth bite of luxury..."
4 star ratingAlpha Hydrox AHA Souffle Review - "Bring on a fresh layer!"
5 star ratingPride and Prejudice (Mini-Series) Review - "Draws you in with whit,...
view more reviews by Wondermima »
Let's Review home | read reviews | write a review | community | discussion boards | guides | popular searches | faq | site map | feedback | labs

Review Categories Autos | Baby | Beauty | Books & Magazines | Clothing | Computers | Education | Electronics | Finance | Food & Drink | Health | Home & Garden | Local Places | Movies & TV | Music & Arts | Office | Pets | Sports | Toys | Travel | Web Sites | Miscellaneous

Viewpoints privacy policy | terms of service | about us

©2006-2008 Viewpoints Network. All rights reserved.